3 ms·
some of it seems so petty It's the harsh logic of resource mobilization. Artists compete for a share of (mostly poor) people's leisure budget by producing song
by anigbrowl 5y ago
some of it seems so petty
It's the harsh logic of resource mobilization. Artists compete for a share of (mostly poor) people's leisure budget by producing songs, hoping that people will like them so much that they'll pay money to hear them from the source. Songs' popularity is a function of novelty and longevity. Radio station operators can't make songs, but they have transmitters that can amplify songs. People listen to the radio to hear songs for free. Radio station operators get kickbacks from the artists or sell advertising, or some mix off the two.
There are more songs than the market can bear at any one, because most people get bored of most songs after a while. The time to play all available songs equally exceeds the number of hours in the day people can listen to the radio (this is the allocation problem streaming solves, at the cost of fragmenting the audience). The radio station wants people to listen as much as possible, so the operators want to play the most popular songs. The listeners decide what is popular, but it takes time for those choices to be communicated back to the station operators and artists, so the station operators try to predict based on the combination of their own musical taste and their ability to get audience information (answering phones at the radio station, using information gained at promotional events etc).
Whereas artists might once have simply trekked from village to village playing their songs and being rewarded with food and sex, that is no longer a viable way to compete against people whose songs are played on the radio. Thus the radio station is now able to hold artists livelihood hostage by their decisions on what 'the popular taste' is at any given time, a symbiotic relationship that can go bad if either party's assessment of the music's popularity drifts too far from reality.
In more advanced societies, media corporations or nations function as amplifiers for ideological or territorial claims which are articulated by social movements appealing to the tastes of populations, and which mostly provide strategies or tactics for their adherents within those populations to maximize their own take from a limited resource pool from which said populations compete to draw.
So, the current political spat over a Supreme Court opinion is the equivalent of one group of legal scholars releasing a diss track of another bunch of legal scholars, delighting or enraging their respective fans. All the intellectual depth and complexity of legal opinions is partly a function over how long the arguments last, in this case ~50 years rather than the few minutes of a typical pop song. The war in Ukraine is a language/cultural identity conflict that has played out over hundreds of years about who gets access to the good agricultural land. I would argue that all social conflict is just elaborated competition over limited environmental resources.