5 ms·
This study/paper is ridiculous. Anecdotal, but I've had lots of dogs growing up. We have five right now. This does not reflect the reality I know. Shiba inu a
by echelon 5y ago
This study/paper is ridiculous.
Anecdotal, but I've had lots of dogs growing up. We have five right now. This does not reflect the reality I know.
Shiba inu act like cats and prefer to spend time away from their person. They frequently get kicked out of dog parks for not being friendly to other dogs. It's documented and well-studied. They're not at all like other dogs.
Corgis are protective, commandeering, and can be aggressive. They'll bully other dogs away from food. But they're incredibly loving, needy, and prone to feeling lonely. Again, it's a breed characteristic.
Australian shepherds are outgoing, cheerful, and tend to be neurotic. A corgi might be needy, but they won't ever express it like an Australian shepherd. A corgi will nudge you. An Aussie will dance on top of you and sometimes freak out.
Look at which dog breeds are most likely to attack humans. There are histograms for all this data. It correlates strongly with breed!
- shard972 5y ago
- cato_the_elder 5y agoIt seems that every day we are getting one step closer to Lysenkoism [1]. [1]: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lysenkoism https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lysenkoism
- Maximus9000 5y agoAlso corgi owner here. Your description is perfect. I've owned two now. My first was pleasant like a nice family golden retriver. My second was exactly how you describe - I like the word "commandeering". Even the queens corgis, who I'm sure got the best training money can buy, were still exactly as you describe. FTA below "For while the Queen adores them, others fear being a victim of their dark side." https://www.macleans.ca/royalty/as-queen-elizabeth-iis-last-corgi-dies-a-baffling-era-comes-to-an-end/ https://www.macleans.ca/royalty/as-queen-elizabeth-iis-last-...
- spike021 5y agoI have a shiba inu and you are exactly right. A lot like cats. Hugely stubborn. Incredibly independent. Exactly as described when I was doing my research originally and deciding to get one. I haven't done a single thing to make him that way, either.
- thephyber 5y agoI don’t find the study ridiculous and I have met dozens of each breed you mentioned. I find that most people assume the entire population of dogs grew up in a house and have been reasonably well looked after. In practice, I have seen lots of dogs that have that kind of history and lots of dogs that have had traumas that cause them to resource guard or be reactive to people and/or other animals (these behaviors are not bred, but are specific to individuals / life experience). I totally agree that some behaviors that have been selected for have very high correlation with the breed, but lots of other behaviors are far less correlated. My Aussie will nudge me with his nose, more like the Corgis you mentioned and less like the Aussies you mentioned. Breed implies correlation of some phenotypes, not causation. In the end, language matters. The title of the Nature article is a Rorschach. In practice, headlines are usually written by someone other than the author and almost always lose significant detail because they are short. Definitions are really important here. I love herding breeds, but they were bred to nip at ankles and butts of livestock. Is that considered an “attack”? Does the person defining what behaviors are an “attack” have an incentive to exclude those small harm incidents? Chihuahuas are notorious for being aggressive and giving nips, but they present as small, quick incidents, whereas large breeds are more likely to bite down and/or swing the neck like a shark does. Does that difference bias the stats reporting/legislation choices? Also, “Pit Bull” isn’t a breed. It is a vague intuition of some of the “bully breeds”. I always have to wonder if people pointing at attack frequency lists which show that inaccurate term are accurate. Did those lists gather data that actually investigated pedigrees or did they eyeball/guess breed based on assumptions?
- hirvi74 5y ago> Shiba inu act like cats and prefer to spend time away from their person. They frequently get kicked out of dog parks for not being friendly to other dogs. It's documented and well-studied. They're not at all like other dogs. Came to these comments just for this breed. Mine is identical to what you describe except he is pretty friendly to other dogs, but my SO and I had to do a ton or work socializing him when he was young.
- livinglist 5y agoI have an Akita and also my previous one was also an Akita, and I bring my dogs to dog parks pretty frequently, I also have a group of people who also have Akita, and my observation is that Akita tends to be loyal but lazy af… they literally been lying on the ground all days long, and not that interested in toys too…
- take_it_not 5y agoI have an Akita as well! mine is not active at all too… I really think it’s in their DNA…
- livinglist 5y agolol yah I really don’t know why though, it’s such an comparison between Akita and shiba…
- take_it_not 5y agoI agree lol Shiba is chill af
- take_it_not 5y agohey do you live in Bay Area we have a dog meet this weekend
- take_it_not 5y agowe would go to the beach in SF, it’s all Akita
- take_it_not 5y agothis is more like a test
- take_it_not 5y agobut if not that’s ok
- take_it_not 5y agothis is more than a test actually
- ranguna 5y agoIt's good that you have personalised experience with the topic but don't let that cloud you judgement around the study. 5 samples is not a good base to conclude anything.