2 ms·
I believe that's actually the wrong question to be asking. If you've got an "opponent", you've already lost. There is nothing in the world that can force them
by jfengel 5y ago
I believe that's actually the wrong question to be asking.
If you've got an "opponent", you've already lost. There is nothing in the world that can force them to change their mind. Even if they're right, they're not out to help you discover that. They're out to change your mind.
Instead, seek out situations where you're not opponents, but partners in seeking the best way for both of you to live together. It's not about seeking "truth", which is something you should both be able to agree on easily. If not, one of you is arguing dishonestly. It doesn't matter which, because the argument isn't going to help figure that out. You have to go find another way.
The world is full of differing opinions, and there's no real way to resolve them. We all have incomplete information. Even with identical information, and goodwill to admit it, you can still reach different conclusions. What we need is not to "defeat an opponent", but to seek ways in which both of you can live with the situation. Which is plenty hard enough even when you're not actively considering each other "opponents".
You'll still have to grapple with the fact that sometimes the things you know are wrong. That's incredibly difficult to get around. It's the essence of science, and of any critical thought. You gain experience through learning as much as you can -- and not with people who have made it important to their egos to change your mind.
So my advice: avoid the situation you're asking about entirely. If you're wrong, you'll find out via somebody more helpful, who is capable of understanding which things you're right about and how your picture of the world is misleading. Plenty of such people exist, but they're not the ones making the most noise.
- eimrine 5y agoI meant both chatting with a friend or reading a science work / whitepaper. You gave me a brilliant answer to former. What about whitepapers, considering of which to believe and which to disagree for me is something that shapes me (my field is cryptocurrencies, if thah matters). But I don't want just a second part of answer, my desire is to find the answer in general, applicable to anything: from math to jurisprudence.
- jfengel 5y agoMy best suggestion is to find as many reasonable people as you can and discuss it with them. (With a focus on "discuss" rather than "argue".) I don't think you can ever get completely outside your own limitations, except perhaps in trivial cases. Everything is constrained by your own subjectivity. But inter-subjectivity reduces the chance that you're objectively wrong. I believe that's the best you can hope for.