6 ms·
Purism Librem 14 review (part 1): The ethical flagship
- amachefe 5y agoIt looks like Lenovo Thinkpad T Series. Solid Linux Machines.
- mr337 5y agoExiting to see more linux options including system76, framework, etc. I'm still really salty about the XPS13 not having proper sleep [1] and looking for other options. [1] - https://www.dell.com/community/XPS/XPS-13-9310-Ubuntu-deep-sleep-missing/m-p/8056343#M91204 https://www.dell.com/community/XPS/XPS-13-9310-Ubuntu-deep-s...
- alias_neo 5y agoHow does it differ from the sleep/hibernate I'm currently using in Ubuntu? My XPS 13 has hardly ever been off since I bought it (2018 model), I enabled sleep/hibernate with a tweak, and it'll last weeks just sitting there "sleeping" if I don't use it.
- simonh 5y agoI'd be interested in seeing an analysis of the hardware, firmware and driver security on this thing. From what I can ascertain the security implementation on some of their phones is horrifying. It brings a different dimension to the reviewer's comment they are a 'known brand among enthusiasts especially in the fields of privacy and information security'. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30761886 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30761886
- fsflover 5y ago> From what I can ascertain the security implementation on some of their phones is horrifying. Their phones run desktop GNU/Linux. Their security is then the same. It's probably not enough for a phone, if you run a lot of untrusted apps, but it's a start. Also, the app store only consists of FLOSS apps. See also: https://source.puri.sm/Librem5/community-wiki/-/wikis/Frequently-Asked-Questions#43-how-secure-is-the-librem-5-compared-to-an-android-phone https://source.puri.sm/Librem5/community-wiki/-/wikis/Freque....
- tomxor 5y agoThe parent is referring to the replacement firmware not the OS and above. This is different from running the same FOSS software on other more closed hardware. It's a valid concern: On the one hand Purism is gradually achieving their intermediate ideal of providing machines with open firmware for all the hardware; On the other hand, if the real life security of that open firmware is poor, it undermines their underlying principle of privacy - To complicate matters it may not be technically worse than the proprietary blobs it replaced, but it's open for all to see. In other words, to achieve real world privacy, it's not enough for the firmware to be open, it must also be secure.
- bo1024 5y agoAn analysis of those things would be very interesting. At a basic level, I appreciate the neutered ME and the killswitches, which already put the laptop at the front of the pack.
- fsflover 5y agoThe laptop also uses Heads, which is indeed known among the security experts: https://docs.puri.sm/PureBoot/Heads/User_Manual.html https://docs.puri.sm/PureBoot/Heads/User_Manual.html.
- megous 5y agoOnly security thing they point out is USB access for the modem, and you can fix that quite easily with a bunch of udev rules, I guess. Disable device auto-probing on the USB port the modem is connected to, and bind the proper modem/ACM driver to the device manually via udev rule. Then there will be no exposure to "all Linux USB drivers" and you'll avoid modem exposing itself as a keyboard and typing things into your console, or whatever. It's the same thing you should be doing on the desktop if you fear untrusted USB devices.
- fsflover 5y agoOr just use Qubes OS with a dedicated VM for usb devices: https://qubes-os.org https://qubes-os.org.
- megous 5y agoThat will still allow execution of kernel code you may not want executed (even though in a VM), and is thus strictly worse. Especially for the modem, which you need to run and interact with all the time on a phone, this sounds like overkill.
- rank0 5y agoNot sure I understand your comment. Of course kernel code is executed in the guest VM…what’s the problem with that? An adversary would have to break Xen security controls to gain access to your other domains.
- megous 5y agoVM has to have some communication bridge to the host, for all the features of the modem. That's still quite a lot of attack surface, once guest VM is compromised. It's better to not expose the needless attack surface rather than just attempting to isolate the attack into a leaky VM.
- rank0 5y ago
- Elyra 5y agoI completely agree with that comment you linked, Purism is either deliberately selling snake oil or are completely clueless. Here's another example of this with them bashing Android/iOS security: > One of the problems with the security measures implemented in Android and iOS is that they restrict the user as much, if not more, than they restrict an attacker. [1] When Android actually has pretty decent sandboxing [2] which I've never felt restricted me as a user, and can actually protect you from malware, unlike their recommendation which is just security theater without a sandbox when it comes to malware. Unless you don't plan on ever installing any apps and personally audit every update yourself (since it's unlikely someone else will audit every single one thoroughly enough), malware and malicious third parties are a much greater threat than Google who is actually pretty transparent about what data they collect and handle it securely and responsibly. [1] https://puri.sm/posts/snitching-on-phones-that-snitch-on-you/ https://puri.sm/posts/snitching-on-phones-that-snitch-on-you... [2] https://source.android.com/security/app-sandbox https://source.android.com/security/app-sandbox
- yjftsjthsd-h 5y ago> When Android actually has pretty decent sandboxing [2] which I've never felt restricted me as a user, and can actually protect you from malware, unlike their recommendation which is just security theater without a sandbox when it comes to malware. Congrats on not hitting it, I guess? Android is absolutely painful if you try to do anything interesting, and it's becoming annoying even for trivial stuff - it was annoying but understandable when they started killing API surface for tasker and termux to use, it was annoying but understandable when they almost broke termux outright, but it moved beyond being understandable when they restricted file access so much that a third-party app can't move files between directories without the OS prompting you to allow the "delete".
- Elyra 5y ago> restricted file access so much that a third-party app can't move files between directories without the OS prompting you to allow the "delete" What use case do you have where you have an app that you want to be able to move files but you don't trust it with the "delete" permission?
- eptcyka 5y agoGiven my previous, ongoing experience with receiving a product from Librem, will this also take years to be shipped after taking payment?
- fsflover 5y agoSince a few months, they have laptops in stock, so shipping occurs within 10 days.
- jvanveen 5y agoStill waiting on a Librem 5 from 2019, while the Puri.sm site claims it takes 52 weeks to deliver new orders. Draw your own conclusions.
- fsflover 5y agoDid you hear about the global supply chain problems? Even Apple suffers from that: https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2021/oct/28/apple-earnings-fourth-quarter-loss-chip-shortages-slow-supply-chain https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2021/oct/28/apple-ear.... (I am waiting for my Librem 5 too by the way!) Edit: Their estimate for the new orders comes from the information from the CPU suppliers, which say the same thing. Every time they can get the CPUs, they ship another bunch of phones. See also: https://forums.puri.sm/t/estimate-your-librem-5-shipping/11272 https://forums.puri.sm/t/estimate-your-librem-5-shipping/112....
- wander_homer 5y agoPurism's shipping claims and estimates have been way way off even before there were any supply chain issues. At one point they even lied to be shipping devices, with pictures from the devices "in the wild", when it later turned out to be prototypes given to some employees.
- fsflover 5y ago> Purism's shipping claims and estimates have been way way off even before there were any supply chain issues This is true, and they had good reasons for that in my opinion: https://source.puri.sm/Librem5/community-wiki/-/wikis/Frequently-Asked-Questions#87-why-has-the-time-to-release-the-librem-5-increased-from-17-to-39-months https://source.puri.sm/Librem5/community-wiki/-/wikis/Freque.... > At one point they even lied to be shipping devices Yes, it did happen: https://source.puri.sm/Librem5/community-wiki/-/wikis/Frequently-Asked-Questions#66-what-was-the-controversy-over-shipping-aspen https://source.puri.sm/Librem5/community-wiki/-/wikis/Freque....
- daenney 5y agoI'm a bit puzzled by the 'ethical' in the title. It only appears in the title, there's no explanation of what makes this laptop ethical and by which measures. The Librem is probably the most available laptop with recent-gen hardware that is the most Free (i.e controllable down to the firmware through Free Software components, and sometimes puts proprietary components behind libre daughter cards). That's a laudable and an impressive achievement all by itself. But when we say ethical, for me that would mean many other things too. Being very repairable and ideally modular so that the user can maintain the device for a long time. Selecting materials that ensure the device is very recyclable and sourcing those materials and the labour needed to assemble them from places that mine them in environmentally conscious ways, that don't employ child labour and pay workers fairly. Purism might be doing some or even all of that, but that information doesn't appear to be available from Purism itself and doesn't look like it's something TuxPhones intends to dig into. Based on the next installments they do at least intend to look at the repairability of the device. Purism itself states: > By removing just a few screws, you can easily replace the battery, wifi module, RAM, or the M.2 ssd.
- fsflover 5y ago> there's no explanation of what makes this laptop ethical and by which measures. They probably mean this: https://www.fsf.org/news/fsf-adds-pureos-to-list-of-endorsed-gnu-linux-distributions-1 https://www.fsf.org/news/fsf-adds-pureos-to-list-of-endorsed.... See also: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25504641 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25504641. It's repairable and upgradable, too: https://puri.sm/posts/beyond-right-to-repair/ https://puri.sm/posts/beyond-right-to-repair/.
- daenney 5y ago> They probably mean this: https://www.fsf.org/news/fsf-adds-pureos-to-list-of-endorsed https://www.fsf.org/news/fsf-adds-pureos-to-list-of-endorsed.... Possibly, yes. But if that's the case then I'd argue the author didn't understand the announcement. It covers PureOS the Debian-derivative published by Purism, not Purism's line of hardware. Purism does some stuff with hardware that the FSF considers "unethical", like the daughter card setup for components where they can't control the firmware. The FSF explicitly states on that page: > It is not a certification of any particular hardware shipping with PureOS. No Purism hardware is "Respects Your Freedom" certified.
- Brian_K_White 5y agoI do value the Purism goal of eradicating all the blobs from the hardware, but reading this I don't feel any envy compared to my Framework which is almost a year old already. I don't have fixed standard ports, but I do have 4 full thunderbolt 4 ports, supporting power/charging on all, and displayport on all, and the modules convert those into whatever combination of dongle-less ports I want. Even though I would like a dongleless ethernet and there is no module for that yet, I still feel like I have way better io than this because what I do have is configurable and way more powerful. Framework's special aim is more about hardware freedom and reusability/repairability, but software freedom is a very close second and they are not exactly slouching on that job. Of course the machine is fully supported under linux for all hardware, and beyond that, they have fwupd support in beta, and most impressively they open sourced the bios a few months ago. Between the open source bios and the ability to install whatever wifi card and storage you want, and the ability to disable the management engine in the cpu yourself by a hack essentially, you get pretty close to eradicating all the blobs. And it's cheaper, even more repairable, and has better io (in a sense). It has hardware camera & mic kills but not hardware rf kill. The screen is 3:2. I routinely run 2 portable external thunderbolt/dp displays. Single usbc/tb3 cable to each display, power and data. I'm not a gamer but other people have used external gpus on it so the ports support that. I also routinely use a tb3 dock on my desktop for gigabit and two monitors and power on a single cable. The plugin modules also means that the usbc ports are also all essentially prophylactic. If you break a usbc port, all you really broke is a $9 passthrough module which you can replace in 2 seconds like swapping a thumb drive. You can even keep using the real usbc port while the replacement module ships, if you didn't already have a spare. 64g removable ddr4, 2t removable nvme, 11th gen i9. I don't suffer for power. Battery life could be better. After tuning I get 6 or 7 hours. Not really up to par for today, although my machine is maxxed out in cpu, disk, and ram which is on me. There is a known issue that some of the plugin usbc modules draw power at all times even when not in use and even when the machine is powered off. So, I happen to use a thunderbolt dock on my desk, and my portable monitors are usbc, so I don't happen to ever actually use the hdmi or dp modules I got, so I don't happen to suffer that power drain because the usbc modules have no electronics. I'd be interested in hearing more about the touchpad and keyboard. The Framework keyboard feels fine and is backlit, but I don't love the layout. And I really don't like the apple-style huge glass touchpad with no buttons. At least the pad is clickable so I can at least still disable taps. And at least it does work well when I must use it. Mostly I use an mx keys keyboard and mx anywhere 3 mouse. I really like the keyboard and touchpad on my x1 carbon 5th gen (2017/2018).
- ineedasername 5y ago>Intel Core i7-10710U Comet Lake processor (RRP $443), which was, apparently, the most powerful laptop-oriented Intels at the time. No, that would be the i7-10870H, which has a higher base & max frequency, and on high performance settings will support sustained workloads much better before throttling down. Intel's "U" chips are one of the the low power flavors. Not horrible for very short burst but pretty bad for sustained loads. I'm using the equivalent H from Gen 9. Work initially "upgraded" me from a 8+ year old xeon to a Gen 9 i7 "U" processor, and it was like stepping into molasses so I insisted on the H. Battery life is significantly worse but I can actually get work done on it, and switch to low power mode if I need to stretch things. (Even then it doesn't last as long as a U, but it's a good compromise for me)
- smoldesu 5y agoThose U-series chips are a bit of a nerd novelty in my book. I've had some kicks and giggles getting my 6600u to run at absurdly low clock speeds (~400mhz) to see how far I could stretch the battery and how usable it was. Pretty much anything under 800mhz is unusable for desktop purposes, but it was a lot of fun playing around with that level of power tuning. Those clocks are much lower than the reported TDP-down stats, so I'm assuming it's only possible to reach those speeds courtesy of the funky sleep states Intel used to put in their Ultrabook CPUs. I don't think you can do similar tricks on new machines. Definitely not the sort of chip you'd want to do anything besides text editing and video streaming on though.
- happycube 5y agoAnd gen8+ U's are much better than previous dual-core chips, which were basically all i3's.
- h-w 5y agoThe Star Labs Starbook MK V has coreboot and intel ME turned off and is one generation newer CPU (11th gen).
- xanaxagoras 5y agoSeems like all of these not-Dell linux laptops have awful speakers, how are they in this?
- h-w 5y agoAlso not good, will confirm when it arrives.
- als0 5y ago> Thanks to Pureboot, the Intel Management Engine (ME) on the processor is disabled: this controversial microcode component, supposed to optimize x86 machine code inside the CPU The author has confused two things here, which are not related. The ME is not microcode, it is a special processor inside the PCH, and is supposed to provide remote management services. Whereas the Intel microcode is a totally different thing - it is an updatable part of the main CPU itself and is used for fixing performance issues, errata, or security issues like Spectre.
- myself248 5y agoAre they not both types of microcode? Just one referred to as Intel Microcode™ which is what they want you to think of as microcode, and the other _also_ being code that executes within the chip outside the user's view, which Intel doesn't refer to as Intel Microcode™ but which still meets the dictionary definition thereof?
- throwlllllllll 5y agoI opened mine and found the headset jack firmware had not been written yet. Does the headphone jack work yet?
- author-of-post 5y agoAuthor here. Works for me (Ubuntu 22.04), although I hear a high-pitched interference when using low-impedance IEMs.