4 ms·
Like Roe, Obergefell would be another decision where if the Supreme Court overruled, it would simply make the law the same as Europe: https://eclj.org/marriage/
by rayiner 5y ago
Like Roe, Obergefell would be another decision where if the Supreme Court overruled, it would simply make the law the same as Europe: https://eclj.org/marriage/the-echr-unanimously-confirms-the-non-existence-of-a-right-to-gay-marriage https://eclj.org/marriage/the-echr-unanimously-confirms-the-...
Likewise in affirmative action. You just listed three things where the supposedly arch conservative Supreme Court is simply making our law the same as France.
- hotpotamus 5y agoThe difference is that the US is a country and Europe is not. Generally speaking it might limit your liberties if one state did not recognize your spouse and another did.
- pdonis 5y ago> Generally speaking it might limit your liberties if one state did not recognize your spouse and another did. That would violate the Full Faith and Credit clause of the US Constitution. Even before Obergefell v. Hodges, states that didn't allow gay couples to marry still had to honor the marriages of gay couples who were married in other states that did allow it.
- hotpotamus 5y agoWas that ever actually settled before Obergefell? My memory is that it was undecided, and Obergefell ended it pretty decisively.
- ryathal 5y agoFree movement in the EU makes that a distinction without a difference for the practical purposes though.
- thatfrenchguy 5y ago> Likewise in affirmative action. You just listed three things where the supposedly arch conservative Supreme Court is simply making our law the same as France. The reason abortion is not legal until 22 weeks in France is because the Netherlands allows it, and our left-and-center governments don't want to spend the political capital on it. Same stupid reason why Democrats haven't passed a bill since Roe vs Wade. That said, I would not want to be a Republican right now, giving people something stupid that they want is the best way to get to stupid-ass results.
- rayiner 5y agoHow do you figure this is bad for republicans? Most people are squishy on abortion. They support some level of abortion, but mostly in the first trimester or for life of mother or birth defects. All of which are consistent with the Mississippi law that the Supreme Court upheld. Roe guarantees elective abortions to the end of the second trimester with few restrictions, and is well to the left of what the public supports: https://www.npr.org/2019/06/07/730183531/poll-majority-want-to-keep-abortion-legal-but-they-also-want-restrictions https://www.npr.org/2019/06/07/730183531/poll-majority-want-.... Generally, when the current law is detached from public opinion, the party that seeks to change the law should stand to benefit from it. Of course liberals will use their vast media and cultural power to dupe people into thinking the Supreme Court just banned abortion. But most people will notice that the Supreme Court didn’t do that when blue states inevitably adopt liberal abortion laws as a reaction. And most of the people who will be really worked up about it will live in blue states that will quickly enact abortion until birth. I suspect most other states will pick some 13-15 week middle ground. I can see Republicans fumbling the ball by trying to ban abortion nationwide. But I can also see a bunch of white liberals reacting to this by shouting “celebrate your abortion” and turning off the mostly Hispanic 3 out of 10 Democrats who identify as “Pro Life,” as well as a bunch of squishy moderates.
- KerrAvon 5y agoApologies, but you are completely detached from political reality. Right now, multiple states have passed legislation banning all abortion, period, no exceptions. Texas’s legislation that SCOTUS refused to halt has made it legally perilous to move out of state to get an abortion. And do you thinkt he cons on the SCOTUS are satisfied with this? They’ll be glad to ban abortion nationwide completely. They’re not gonna leave it to the states.
- remarkEon 5y ago>And do you thinkt he cons on the SCOTUS are satisfied with this? They’ll be glad to ban abortion nationwide completely. Did you read what Alito wrote? He's explicitly stating he doesn't want SCOTUS ruling on the legality of abortion. How, precisely, would SCOTUS "ban abortion" in this scenario?
- comrh 5y agoIndividual countries have passed laws protecting gay marriage or had restrictions struck down in the courts though.
- rayiner 5y agoAnd the same thing was true in individual US states before Obergefell. Iowa legalized same sex marriage when California banned it by referendum.
- hindsightbias 5y agoThey’re just getting started. 30 days: http://webserver1.lsb.state.ok.us/cf_pdf/2021-22%20INT/SB/SB1553%20INT.PDF http://webserver1.lsb.state.ok.us/cf_pdf/2021-22%20INT/SB/SB... South Dakota is working on 5 weeks. There are something like a 100 state bills in work this year.
- rayiner 5y agoAnd abortion is illegal in Poland, and was illegal in Ireland until recently. So what? Somehow the folks in France manage to be part of the same EU as the folks in Poland without getting too worked up about abortion laws that don’t affect them.