3 ms·
Of course he's in the community; he's as far as I know the #1 representative of it to the common people. Some rationalist blogs are all about polycules, some ar
by astrange 5y ago
Of course he's in the community; he's as far as I know the #1 representative of it to the common people. Some rationalist blogs are all about polycules, some are about being weirdly friendly to right-wing online communities like NRX, and some are about a modern religion they've invented around worshipping AI and effective altruism. He's more on the latter 2 of the 3.
(Probably also what she was talking about with eugenics, since they're extremely in love with the idea of "intelligence" in general, that they have it, certain other people don't because of genetics and the liberals don't want to talk about it, and that it'd be bad if computers had a lot more of it. I've seen this any time I read his comments.)
> I wonder if you also believe that post is just a wasteful collection of philosophy anthropomorphizing misunderstood ML models.
Rather, they're anthropomorphizing something called "AGI" that can only exist in their imagination, decided it's bad, and decided modern AI research is "AGI" because it has the same letters in the name.
nb apparently there's some kind of anti-SSC hater community out there I've never looked up, someone accused me of reading it before I think? I ain't done nothin.
- brian_cloutier 5y ago> some kind of anti-SSC hater community There's one called sneerclub but there might be more. > something called "AGI" that can only exist in their imagination You're claiming it's impossible for non-humans to be smarter than humans?
- astrange 5y ago> There's one called sneerclub but there might be more. Sounds right. Seems like a waste of time, though I'd rather people read Gwern or Meaningness than SSC for their internet philosophers. > You're claiming it's impossible for non-humans to be smarter than humans? I'm claiming the only reason the AGI in their imagination is taking over the world is that they've imagined it's doing that. Also, that me saying "no that won't happen" is a superior method of thinking about it to rationalist decision theory, because it's immune to Russell's teapots like this. Presumably, this can be disproven if I'm killed in a robot war. I'm okay with an AGI existing insofar as it acts like humans already do, but think the unknown unknowns are going to prevent it from being real insofar as it acts less like any currently existing thing with a brain. i.e. I don't think they've defined "smarter" and are using it to mean "omnipotent".