3 ms·
Did ~$200 million dollars worth of electricity & hardware depreciation get burnt as part of this land sale? If so, I'd say that it's close to 'wasted', given t
by vkou 5y ago
Did ~$200 million dollars worth of electricity & hardware depreciation get burnt as part of this land sale?
If so, I'd say that it's close to 'wasted', given that as I understand, the only thing of value that has been created is only useful for financial speculation.
We're paying people to dig ditches, and then fill them. Just because the ditchdiggers got paid doesn't mean their effort isn't wasted!
- tshaddox 5y agoI don't think the way it works is that every blockchain transaction of value X requires an equivalent cost X (denominated in USD) of electricity usage and hardware depreciation.
- vkou 5y ago... Right. Duh. If this was simply a surprise pay-day for miners (as opposed to the real cost of running the network), you are right, in that extent. In that case, yes, from a productivity & resource usage point of view, this wasn't a waste of $200 million.
- rglullis 5y agoNo, it didn't. The amount of electricity used doesn't increase because of network congestion, and with Ethereum's mining reward system, there is no incentive for miners to increase their hash rate just for high-congestion moments. Lastly, these reports really need to stop denominating things in USD. 64k ETH were burned, the dollar amount is not related to it.
- whimsicalism 5y agoNot going to comment on the specific claims here, but "speculation" is often a useful activity if we care about planning for the long-term and adequately allocating resources.
- vkou 5y agoIt is, if it actually results in useful, productive, real-world work to be done more efficiently. I understand why people may want to trade futures, or hedge against instability in FOREX or interest rates, and how this spawns a side-industry of derivatives traders and speculators, etc, etc. Unfortunately, the ratio of speculation to productive real-world work done by the crypto space seems to be ~0, compared to speculation in most of the real-world economy. If all of these ICOs and NFTs were producing valuable goods (food, medicine, shelter, widgets, entertainment[1]) left and right, more efficiently than the traditional economy, I wouldn't accuse the space of being purely speculative. [1] Well, it does produce some entertainment...
- whimsicalism 5y agoStablecoin adoption in the developing world seems to be of value. Compensating artists and thus incentivizing artwork seems probably good too. But I'm not very familiar with the space as I've said.