3 ms·
From the article: He said Webster's actions were more serious because he did not just access his own or a mate's account, but hundreds of other customer accoun
by josephg 15y ago
From the article:
He said Webster's actions were more serious because he did not just access his own or a mate's account, but hundreds of other customer accounts, to prove the security flaw was real.
"While we were appreciative of him showing us a weakness in our security systems the size of the downloads concerned us greatly and the fact that it was a major breach of the privacy provisions of our members," Dwyer said in a phone interview.
The guy didn't just find and report on a vulnerability. He also scraped a whole heap of private customer details ('to prove the problem was real'). If his intentions were pure, he shouldn't have downloaded & saved the private information of hundreds of customers. First State Super overreacted, but I can understand why they're nervous that he might keep the data.
- wpietri 15y agoSeriously? I'd say checking that the vulnerability works on "hundreds of customers" out of 770,000 is a reasonable thing to do to see if it's really there and to get a bit of proof. I could easily imagine quickly banging out some shell one-liner with seq+wget to see if it wasn't a fluke. First State Super shouldn't have worried about this guy. If he were evil, he wouldn't have told them. If some problem later developed with those few hundred people, they'd know who to nab. This is just scapegoating, presumably driven by IT people trying to distract execs from their total incompetence.