3 ms·
Because those transactions cause other transactions, which cause others, and so on and so forth. You'd have to reset the market for the day. Imagine how pissed
by ceejayoz 5y ago
Because those transactions cause other transactions, which cause others, and so on and so forth. You'd have to reset the market for the day.
Imagine how pissed you'd be if you made money off Knight's mistake and it all just disappeared the next day.
- strgcmc 5y agoExcept, well, cancelling transactions obviously does happen, sometimes: https://www.reuters.com/business/lme-suspends-nickel-trading-day-after-prices-see-record-run-2022-03-08/ https://www.reuters.com/business/lme-suspends-nickel-trading... Knight was probably too messy to rollback cleanly, but that just means it's a matter of cost/complexity/politics... if you're a big enough player, then the exchange will do you favors, like in the LME case. Free markets, lol
- rubyskills 5y agoThis is much easier to do in a centralized futures market. I can't imagine a rollback in stocks being easy or possible.
- bfm 5y agoFrom the OP Rules were established after the “flash crash” of May 2010 to govern when trades should be canceled. Knight’s buying binge did not drive up the price of the purchased stocks by more than 30 percent, the cancellation threshold, except for six stocks. Those transactions were reversed. In the other cases, the trades stood.
- ceejayoz 5y ago> The LME announced that all trades will be voided from midnight until 8:15 a.m. on Tuesday when trading stopped and added that it was considering a closure of several days. > "People will be asking if this really a functioning market... This is meant to be a market of last resort and people can't get inventories to deliver against positions," said Colin Hamilton, managing director of commodities research at BMO Capital Markets. There’s gonna be a pretty high threshold for this sort of thing. Higher than “one company fucked up and wants a do-over”.
- rubyskills 5y agoExactly this. If you're a market maker, likely your trades impact your own trades too. As you accumulate a position, your average price is going up with it. Trades should not just roll back because one large hedge fund screwed up. Imagine being a retail trader with that expectation. Would be nice!