4 ms·
>You shouldn't be able to license a "technology" unless it's a marketable product. You just gave this long explanation of why it's reasonable to charge LG for
by dpark 15y ago
>You shouldn't be able to license a "technology" unless it's a marketable product.
You just gave this long explanation of why it's reasonable to charge LG for Super AMOLED licensing. AMOLEDs are not marketable products. No one buys an LCD randomly to keep in their pocket. They buy a phone that happens to use an AMOLED display.
Regardless of whether the patents in question are valid, your argument makes no sense. Basically no one ever licenses entire products except for end-user licenses. When it comes to licensing for other companies' production, they generally license various technologies which are not by themselves marketable products.
- jdc 15y agoNo one buys an LCD randomly to keep in their pocket. Straw-man. A phone maker buys an LCD to make a phone. Or an AMOLED display to build a more desirable phone. Marketable doesn't mean "marketable to end-users". It means marketable to anyone, including other businesses.
- Tloewald 15y agoThis definition of marketable is Circular. If I can sell you a license it's marketable.
- dpark 15y agoAs Tloewald said, this is begging the question. If I can sell you a license to a patent so that you can build a more desirable phone, how is that different from selling you a display for the same reason? If there's a market, then it's marketable. Software patents are often attacked with silly arguments that don't hold up to scrutiny. Software patents should be fought with reasoned arguments, not invalid logic.