3 ms·
Option B: Remove the computer and use a cable between the throttle body and the accelerator pedal, as was traditional for about 3/4 of a century.
by bob1029 5y ago
Option B: Remove the computer and use a cable between the throttle body and the accelerator pedal, as was traditional for about 3/4 of a century.
- MengerSponge 5y agoBecause physical throttle cables never got stuck for that 3/4 of a century.
- MarcoZavala 5y ago
- bob1029 5y agoThe failure mode of a physical throttle cable is almost always much more gradual than with a computer bug, which can effectively kill you instantly without warning.
- jandrese 5y agoMy grandfather had a truck on his farm with an occasionally sticky throttle. He failed to mention this when I had just gotten my learners permit and was trying to get some practice. So the family hopped in the back and he took shotgun so we could drive over to the cattle pasture and check on the herd. Halfway there I hit a bump in the dirt road and accidentally smacked the throttle with my foot, which causes it to stick on the floorboard just as we are approached the stream to crossing. Luckily for everyone involved my grandfather knew what to do and slapped the stick into neutral before we all went careening over the rocky crossing. I was a bit slower getting the clutch in and the brakes on being a new driver. It was pretty weird feeling stopped in the middle of a stream with brakes fully on and the engine roaring. He then reached over and turned off the key, making me feel like an even bigger idiot for not thinking of it. The point is if you're not mentally prepared for a runaway engine it's hard to figure it out on the fly in the mere moments you have before your doom. Follow on note: Grandpa gave that truck to my uncle a few years later and my uncle managed to blow up the engine almost immediately. Turns out some of the head bolts were not fully tightened down at the factory but my grandfather drove it so gently that it wasn't a problem except for a persistent but low grade oil consumption issue for its entire life.
- MengerSponge 5y ago"almost" is doing a lot of work in that sentence
- cameronh90 5y agoI had a car from the 90s that suddenly developed a sticky throttle. Of course you just put the clutch in and nothing to worry about.
- jacquesm 5y agoThey did, but at least you were aware of it, besides, throttle cables breaking was far more common than them getting stuck. And typically if a throttle cable got stuck it wasn't really the cable but the butterfly valve attached to it that got stuck, usually on gunk in the throttlebody itself.
- Toutouxc 5y agoI have a feeling you DO understand that going back to driver-operated throttles would mean going back to 90s emissions standards, but you just don't care, am I right?
- salawat 5y agoYou know, there are those that see the slow delegation and abstraction away from operators the finer details of operating a machine and locking them behind unauditable, undocumented blackboxes to be a regression and power grab, right?