3 ms·
People lived in deserts all across the US for tens of thousands of years and got by just fine and never had to pay a dime for water. This isn't a desert climat
by krapp 5y ago
People lived in deserts all across the US for tens of thousands of years and got by just fine and never had to pay a dime for water.
This isn't a desert climate problem, it's a "capitalism charging money for something that should be free" and "modern civilization having no concept of ecological balance" problem.
- JumpCrisscross 5y ago> it's a "capitalism charging money for something that should be free"…problem It’s mostly the opposite. If we put a price on water, with the first 50,000 gallons per residence being free or subsidised [1], the problem would self correct. Water-heavy industries would be priced out. A budget would emerge for conservation. We don’t get this, however, because the state’s heaviest water users, certain agriculture and industry, have convinced enough of the urban population that water pricing is some capitalist scam. (Analogous to how landowners convinced renters that the enemy was the employers.) The story of modern California’s woes is one of special interests co-opting a gullible anti-capitalist slice of the populace. [1] https://water.ca.gov/News/News-Releases/2021/Nov-21/State-Agencies-Recommend-Indoor-Residential-Water-Use-Standard https://water.ca.gov/News/News-Releases/2021/Nov-21/State-Ag...
- jjoonathan 5y agoAre you kidding me? Water and farmland were perpetual sources of ancient conflict, even if you fail to normalize for population density. Prices are how you push back and achieve balance. Wishful thinking is not a solution.
- YATA1 5y ago
- AnimalMuppet 5y ago> and got by just fine Or maybe not. The Anasazi left a bunch of uninhabited ruins. Current thinking is that drought played a big part in why their population declined.
- ncmncm 5y agoLikewise, cf. The Catastrophe, when every coastal city around the Mediterranean was sacked c. BCE 1190, beginning a 300-year dark age, which appears to have started with a multi-year region-wide drought; although it is hard to be sure at this remove, especially when record-keeping evaporated along with civilization itself. Archaeology has had to fill in the blanks.