3 ms·
Everyone saying 'we need to grow more crops!' needs to see that the futures markets deal with exactly this. As people see high futures prices for corn, they'l
by londons_explore 5y ago
Everyone saying 'we need to grow more crops!' needs to see that the futures markets deal with exactly this. As people see high futures prices for corn, they'll grow more corn because it's more profitable. Some farmers will switch from livestock to corn.
Others who have storage facilities will make money by buying now to sell later and make use of the price difference.
At a certain point, prices get too high for making bioethanol. And that gets eaten by people instead.
Basically - there is no shortage because markets will do their job and mean there is always availability of all goods.
The only time there will be a shortage is when governments do things like cap prices or restrict exports/imports.
- modo_mario 5y ago> Some farmers will switch from livestock to corn. This switch can take too long and would need to take place in an industry often already razor tin margins thanks to big chains (which can contribute to inflexibility) and then plants take time to grow and depend on the seasons, etc. Also fertilisers go into both the livestock and the corn feed. >Basically - there is no shortage because markets will do their job and mean there is always availability of all goods. A shortage doesn't need to mean people are starving. If prices of staple foods go up enough it too causes societal unrest. (See Arab spring where bread prices went up, governments tried to protect their peg to the dollar, etc) >The only time there will be a shortage is when governments do things like cap prices or restrict exports/imports. Well here we see that happening when fuels and other components for fertilisers and some things like vegetable oils are affected by war.
- taylodl 5y agoThe markets can't solve problems due to lack of critical resources. Market theory rests on the assumption that all needed resources are readily available. Demand can be met my using capital to create more manufacturing facilities. Remove that assumption and market theory essentially collapses. Where market theory can still save the day is finding alternatives. If a key resource needed for the production and distribution of goods is missing then market forces will tend to produce an alternative. That works so long as an actual replacement exists and the cost of the replacement is in line with the original. Water is an irreplaceable resource - if you don't have water and you need it for production then you're pretty much screwed. The market won't "solve" that problem for you. If, as in this case, you need fertilizer then there may be an alternative but it may take several years to ramp up the production of that alternative and that alternative may be considerably more expensive than the original. This scenario leads to food shortages, food insecurity, and spiraling food costs. The market can't prevent these realities. In short, markets are just a tool and like all tools you need to understand their usefulness and limitations.
- pm90 5y agoIndia, the 2/3 largest producer of wheat/rice has strict controls on exports. Other countries will impose restrictions when they realize their poor will rise up in riots. One theory for arab spring is that it started because of rising food prices. Food is just not like other commodities. Shortages lead not just to recessions but revolutions. Any Government and society not paying close attention and investing in either ramping up domestic production or stockpiling is going to have a really bad time.