4 ms·
Having spent way too much time down this rabbit hole, here's an opinion I synthesized from those way smarter than me. If Russia fully mobilizes (ie, declares t
by bryanlarsen 5y ago
Having spent way too much time down this rabbit hole, here's an opinion I synthesized from those way smarter than me.
If Russia fully mobilizes (ie, declares this a war, calls up reserves, etc) AND the west slows their support, Russia can win.
Ukraine has the people and the will to win, but without heavy weapons, ammo, the training to use western weapons and logistical support that's not enough. Right now Biden is trying to pass a $33B support bill. But Congress is playing their stupid politics and if it doesn't pass the alliance will probably fracture and Ukraine will also likely lose support from other Western nations.
Russia is currently manpower & materiel constrained. They can fix the former by fully mobilizing. The latter is harder to fix, but they have destroyed Ukraine's production. So they if Ukraine is cut off from Western arms shipments....
But even after winning Russia still has the problem of occupying Ukraine. It's not clear that's possible with flattening the country.
- konart 5y ago>If Russia fully mobilizes Very big if here. People over here are not very eager to go to the frontline. Painting Z on your car is one thing. Marching to your almost certain death is another. >heavy weapons I was under the impression that heave weapons are on their way already though? Old but usable T72's from Poland and some tanks\howitzers from other countries. Surely they still need fuel, ammo and training but right now it looks like Ukraine has some time. > occupying Ukraine. I think the current plan is to destroy as much as possible (fuel, storages etc), cut off from support as much as possible and maybe enter Moldova.
- bryanlarsen 5y agoYes, a Russian victory requires (at least) two massive IF's. I'm mostly just pushing back against the narrative that a Ukrainian victory is inevitable. If it's seen as inevitable, then it becomes easier to justify not delivering the help they need.
- jacquesm 5y agoOr the opposite, which I think is more likely: if it is not seen as inevitable then that will justify not delivering the help they need, ensuring the outcome matches the prediction. The biggest problem right now is to maintain unity across all of the countries that are on the other side of this line, Russia has a much easier job there than the West, with Hungary and Switzerland as the latest in the pack of useful idiots carrying Putin's water for him. With friends like that you don't need enemies.