3 ms·
You're right, there's more left. But as it gets harder to extract, prices will rise. We're already reduced to blowing up mountaintops in Virginia to get coal, o
by graeme 15y ago
You're right, there's more left. But as it gets harder to extract, prices will rise. We're already reduced to blowing up mountaintops in Virginia to get coal, or melting the soil of Alberta to get tar. The energy return on investment (EROI) of those sources is much lower than the old Saudi oil.
Optimistically, those sources might help ease a transition. We'd still have energy to power things, and the higher prices would encourage switching.
But there are still dangers. We only have a limited amount of carbon we can still afford to put in the atmosphere. And it will be difficult to run all of our current activities and invest in new energy sources and do so as the price of energy rises.
The question remains: if we switch, what are we switching to?We're currently using energy that was stored for us over millions of years. It's highly concentrated. Renewables must make do with incoming solar energy.
Maybe people will warm to nuclear, but that has its own issues.
- Retric 15y agoEROI for blowing up mountaintops in Virginia is significantly better than 1970's saudi Oil. It's also better than directly minding the stuff. Which is why the cost of coal is so 1/10th the price of Oil per unit energy. PS: People talk about Oil like it's the single most important energy source out there, but it's only important because it used to be so cheap.
- schiffern 15y agoThe EROI for blowing up mountaintops ignores the externalized costs of the activity: water pollution, habitat destruction (and the loss of associated ecosystem services), damage from explosive concussions, and ultimately a locality that sacrifices its long-term health for a handful of temporary jobs. And this argument even yields to the HN party line that states that the value of undeveloped natural spaces is zero.
- wlievens 15y agoIt's a bit cynical to call that "the HN party line". There's surely a bunch of hardcore libertarians out here who would hold that opinion (by which I won't implicate that any libertarian would) but I doubt it's a majority.
- Retric 15y agoWhen it comes to energy, I am vary pro wind power and feel solar/fusion are both going to be viable in my lifetime. However, EROI is a measure of the amount of energy it costs to develop an energy source which is both a simple measurement and poorly understood by a lot of people. So, while I dislike coal for a number of reasons, I do feel the need to bring it up when people get all doom and gloom over Oil.
- jacques_chester 15y agoYou can make oil out of natural gas, coal, wood, hemp oil, cane sugar. Anything that has carbohydrates can, with an energy investment, be turned into a different carbohydrate. Gas and coal would be first because they're closer to petroleum and massively abundant, but there's no chemical reason why other substitutes can't be used in the very long term.