3 ms·
I work at an art school and deal with art more or less for the past two decades. My mother is a painter. I don't think you are wrong. Yet in practise there are
by atoav 5y ago
I work at an art school and deal with art more or less for the past two decades. My mother is a painter.
I don't think you are wrong. Yet in practise there are many, many people who confuse good crafts with good art. Painting photorealistically for example is certainly a skill that needs some time to be mastered. But it doesn't mean that what the painter did resulted necessarily in art.
And if you closely this sort of coincided with the rise of photography. Before photography a realistic painting was the only way to create a picture that could actuallt show onlookers a slice of a different time or place. This was one of the values of painting. Just think about how much people like to share images nowadays. But to do it back in the day, you needed a painter, a decent chunk of money and time.
When photography started to gain traction this changed. Suddenly painting was robbed of one of its former functions. Depicting places and people was something photography could do better, faster and cheaper.
This means painting had to move into the other direction of depicting things that photography could not and it did.
But as it is today if you compared the opinions of a random sample of the population to those who deal with art a lot, you'd find that the general population will often confuse crafts with arts. You can impress many people more with a photorealistic painting of a totally uninteresting subject, than you could impress with an interesting abstract painting. In the art world that would be flipped. There crafts would be seen as something that one can learn and aquire, but the crux lies in how you apply it and what you do with it.
It is good that anybody can claim something to be art. But the claim alone is worthless — they have to believe you it is. Art is something that has a social dimension, the discussion about it is part of the thing. And just like with music it is totally acceptable that you dislike parts of it. Not everybody has to like japanese harsh noise, or even count it as music for example.
- lloeki 5y ago> the general population will often confuse crafts with arts. You can impress many people more with a photorealistic painting of a totally uninteresting subject, than you could impress with an interesting abstract painting Perfectly highlighted by the usual comments: "how is this art? this looks like my 5yo could draw that doodle" "how is this art? it's just a couple of coloured squares"