4 ms·
One of the most annoying things things in science fiction is this plot line: the earth is running out of food, so several hundred thousand people get on a big
by bryanlarsen 15y ago
One of the most annoying things things in science fiction is this plot line: the earth is running out of food, so several hundred thousand people get on a big ark ship to the nearest star. They then feed themselves in a few cubic kilometres simply using nuclear energy to power giant greenhouses.
Why couldn't they have done that on earth? Using nuclear power plants to desalinate water and power vertical greenhouses, back of the envelope calculations show the maximum population of the earth at somewhere around 1 TRILLION people.
Sure, that would make food more expensive, but given how dramatically the cost of food has dropped over time, we could deal with it.
For example, the price of a bushel of wheat has been within an order of magnitude of 1 UK pound for the last 1000 years. The price of everything else has increased over time, but wheat hasn't.
- tsuyoshi 15y agoRight, so energy can be substituted for arable land. But I wonder if the real limit to human population is mineral-based, rather than energy-based. Every person needs a certain portion of different minerals: calcium, iron, potassium, magnesium, phosphorus, zinc, selenium, etc. Maybe we would run out of one of those minerals before we would run out of energy? This could be a topic for science fiction. We run out of zinc, and then have to send an unmanned spaceship over to some other galaxy to mine some zinc... but there would have to be some other complication, because unmanned spaceflight is boring.
- ctdonath 15y agoPot growers manage to substitute energy for arable land.
- jacques_chester 15y agoI once calculated that at a constant doubling rate of every 15 years, the human race would need to use all of the resources of the asteroid belt in about 12,000 years. There's a lot of stuff out there.
- bryanlarsen 15y agoWe're not going to run out of minerals. Choose a mineral, any mineral, even a trace mineral. Look on Wikipedia to see what percentage of the earth's crust it makes up. (for example, iron is 5%). Do the math and realize that we've got thousands to millions of years worth of minerals left. Sure, we can run out of "easy" deposits. We did that for Copper decades ago. Copper mines today are essentially giant processing plants that extract the tiny amount of copper in pretty much ordinary dirt -- "copper ore" these days only has about 10 times as much copper per kg as the stuff in your backyard.
- sneak 15y agoI've always wondered why more people don't discuss a future based around the idea of practically unlimited nuclear energy + practically unlimited clean water from desalinization + practically unlimited hydrogen from electrolysis. It seems that that would solve a vast number of problems, no?
- FrojoS 15y agoAs far as I understand, unless we develop reliable fast breeders, there is hardly enough fuel for that many nuclear plants. I thought the Japanese were on a good way to build an energy economy based on breeders. Now, these efforts might be on halt.
- ctdonath 15y agoAFAIK, that's entirely a political issue at this point. We have the technology, we just are just skittish to process the fuel thru the bomb-suitable phase, and haven't correlated catastrophic failure with building the facility on a tsunami-and-earthquake-prone site. Psychology, not technology.
- ctdonath 15y agoAh, time to crunch the numbers again... 149M sq km total land 15M sq km farmland 7000M people So by dividing current farmland by population and rounding the result up a bit, each person gets a plot 47x47m for 603 sq ft for living and the rest for farmland. Assuming half the land is rank (unusable) wilderness, that roughs out to an optimistic carrying capacity of 33000M people. But that’s not taking into account high-efficiency farming or compact housing. So methinks the alarm has been prematurely sounded. We’re still a ways from 33 billion occupants, and between technology and nature methinks that issue will be...adjusted.
- lupatus 15y agoPlus, regularly-efficient farming can be greatly expanded. For example, a lot of former cropland in the United States' southern region (think former Confederate states) was purposefully reforested after WWII because agricultural overproduction was one of the causes of the Great Depression. Basically, the United States produced more food than it could sell domestically, sell internationally, and give away. As another example, the organized high-latitude herding of reindeer is practically non-existent in North America, and I suspect in a similar position in Eurasia. Reindeer literally thrive on moss, breed like bunnies, and taste like filet mignon. Reversing just these two examples with today's normal farming know-how will produce substantially more food.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- coldarchon 15y agoalthough I like people who use facts, please enlighten me, how do they cook their food? And why is there such a huge desertification in countries with an exploding population? And if hunger is so bad for a population, how did Sudan manage to multiply it's population by 20 within the last 100 years?
- ctdonath 15y agoSorry if my 6-sentence post failed to provide encyclopedic coverage of the issue. (Snarky start aside...) I'm a bit confused by the prevalence of the "so how do they cook it?" question in such discussions when I point out that one can live sustainably, if not well, on very little. It's as though many have never gone camping and cooked over a fire. Gas/electric stoves and metal cookware are recent developments which humans got by without for a long time - and many still do. For starters, shish-kabobs come to mind for cooking veggies on a stick. In a cramped/austerity situation, little actually needs cooking, given that much can be either eaten raw, or just dried and eaten straight or reconstituted as needed. What needs cooking can be over a fire using the dried inedible remainder of the plants. Stir-fry Solar ovens are not hard to build. High-tech solutions, at the other extreme, could provide very efficient heat sources. (We need not abandon high- and future-tech for high-population-density scenarios; to the contrary, there would be great motivation to advance technology to match demands for efficiency.) Desertification correlating with population growth? Will have to look into it more. Causation is not obvious (which influences which how & more?). Seems people _are_ figuring out how to feed a population with little resources, translating to sustainability with small per-capita footprint. BTW: Gladwell's "Outliers" spends a lot of time researching how ancient/remote/low-tech/cramped/austerity populations managed to feed themselves with few farming resources. For one, Japanese rice farming was a tour-de-force of squeezing as many calories out of a very limited space per capita. Worth a read.
- doyoulikeworms 15y ago>The price of everything else has increased over time, but wheat hasn't. By what measure? Over the long run, prices have surely fallen for just about everything.
- bdunbar 15y agothe earth is running out of food, so several hundred thousand people get on a big ark ship to the nearest star. I cannot think of a story with that plot. But I am not the world's biggest fan: what story is that? Why couldn't they have done that on earth? Because 'people stay home and grow food' is not a very exciting story.
- cpeterso 15y agoOne example is The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy, but there are many more examples of "generation ships" on tvtropes.org: http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/GenerationShips http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/GenerationShips
- bdunbar 15y agoMy favorite generation ship story is Heinlein's 'Orphans of the Sky'. I was asking the poster about the specific plot point he mentioned: running out of food.