3 ms·
> I think the above definition, perhaps unwittingly, robs us of traditional value in art. By that above definition, a classical greco-roman statue that doesn't
by bitwize 5y ago
> I think the above definition, perhaps unwittingly, robs us of traditional value in art. By that above definition, a classical greco-roman statue that doesn't challenge anyone's ideas or perception cannot be art.
It was art in its day, but a modern sculptor creating Greco-Roman statuary is less an artist than Marcel Duchamp exhibiting an upside down urinal, because the act of exhibiting the urinal as art calls into question the unconscious assumptions about what art should look like. Right? Reiterating the values that came before is conservatism; and conservatism is the death of art because there's no thinking involved. Art must therefore force its audience to think in order to qualify.
You are using a definition of art that hasn't been conventionally accepted ever since Duchamp, who once said that art is that which challenges the notion of what is art (so, pretty much Xe's definition). Duchamp also said "Art is either plagiarism or revolution". So unless you are doing Greco-Roman statuary in a manner that shatters people's expectations of Greco-Roman statuary, your statues are a jejune copy of what has come before -- and therefore not art. Capisce?
- yakubin 5y agoWas Leonardo da Vinci not an artist when he drew the Vitruvian Man? Were all Renaissance sculptors and painters for that matter not artists, since they were copying the Greco-Roman style? Are script-writers of House of Cards not artists due to writing a Shakespearean play? Is George Lucas not an artist because he did not make anyone question what art is? > Duchamp also said "Art is either plagiarism or revolution". So unless you are doing Greco-Roman statuary in a manner that shatters people's expectations of Greco-Roman statuary, your statues are a jejune copy of what has come before -- and therefore not art. Here is a contradiction. First plagiarism is listed as an example of art, to then be described as "not art". Also, I think that art which sticks to established understanding of what art is isn't necessarily plagiarism. Just because there were plenty of standard 3-act structured plays/films, does not mean that subsequent attempts are plagiaristic. Otherwise art would be castrated to just form, when in fact it is a marriage of form and substance. I think this fixation on "subverting expectations" comes from self-centredness of some artists. Maybe if you dedicate your whole life to just art, you don't have other experiences to draw from to create something about more than art itself. And so art becomes a simulacrum.
- bombcar 5y agoYeah, by that definition a badly done copy of a famous statue would be "art" because it falls short of a copy, but a brand new statue perfectly executed in the style of a famous statue would not be art, because it doesn't shatter anything. I feel too many people want to define art such that they "love all art" - when art can be done well, or poorly, and you can like or not like it even if done well. Now saying "when is art done" may be more complicated; the designer perfecting a perfume to capture a particular scent and be long-lasting and non-toxic is doing art (and other works) - but the machine that eventually makes gallons and gallons of the perfume to put in little bottles is not "making art" even if the result is a "work of art". Art requires intent.
- bitwize 5y ago> Yeah, by that definition a badly done copy of a famous statue would be "art" because it falls short of a copy, but a brand new statue perfectly executed in the style of a famous statue would not be art, because it doesn't shatter anything. L.H.O.O.Q. is famous and influential in ways that a modern Mona Lisa style portrait would not be. Hey, I don't make the rules.
- JetAlone 5y ago>It was art in its day, but a modern sculptor creating Greco-Roman statuary is less an artist than Marcel Duchamp exhibiting an upside down urinal, because the act of exhibiting the urinal as art calls into question the unconscious assumptions about what art should look like. Right? No. Wrong. Tradition and change are beautiful and exciting together, more than either is apart. Art that lacks one or the other attribute is every bit as much art as art that has the opposite, or both. Neither of these attributes belong tossed into an upside down urinal. Tradition conveys its patterns forwards, and change allows us to mutate from that baseline of skills and methods to discover new thought and beauty. Pure conservatism would indeed rob us of new thought, just as pure progressivism robs us of beauty now. If the professional art establishment tries to snip a wing off of the wondrous bird we as humans have discovered, I shall reject it and revolt. Even if all I can do is to crudely glue it back on to present the hobbled bird to a fractured and confused audience and only a few recognize what I am doing to resuscitate our vision of its form, it is a start. I will remain faithful to what it really is to observe and create art. If you can't see the truth in that, as I said before, I have very little interest in communicating with you.