3 ms·
You could apply the same approach to the homelessness problem: "Let's just bite the bullet, end the land ownership system and auction the land, using the money
by kragen 5y ago
You could apply the same approach to the homelessness problem: "Let's just bite the bullet, end the land ownership system and auction the land, using the money to pay back the cost." I guess the idea is that every house is up for rent every year, rent decided by auction and payable to the government, who then compensates the former owners?
Are you in favor of that approach to land tenure? If not, why would water rights be different?
- cycomanic 5y agoThe solution is actually straight forward. Recognise that property rights didn't just start with the Europeans coming to the americas, so all current land ownership is illegal. Now this obviously would open a whole different can of worms, but I always find it amazing that people argue you can't do things because of property rights while all land ownership in the US is essentially based on illegally taking the rights of previous occupiers.
- kragen 5y agoIt's not illegal, the thieves passed laws to legalize it. Illegal and immoral aren't the same. I think your usage of the word "solution" here is also at odds with common usage.
- replygirl 5y ago> property rights didn't just start with the Europeans coming to the americas, so all current land ownership is illegal ehh, property rights here sorta did come out of colonization, much of the land was bought from communities who didn't have a concept of private property. it's not a technical issue of legality, it's that this was unjust and wrong. > Now this obviously would open a whole different can of worms potentially undermining the legal and economic foundation of contemporary tribal sovereignty, for one.
- slavik81 5y agoIn some ways, a land-value tax is kind of like that. A LVT of x% is equivalent to the government taking x% of your land and making you buy it back from them at market value. Perhaps that indicates that the more palatable solution would be a tax on the exercise of water rights.
- coryrc 5y agoWater is fungible. Land is not.
- kragen 5y agoLand is not fungible for agriculture or mining, but for residential purposes, dry land is pretty fungible, just not portable. In agriculturally-relevant quantities, neither is water, at least not without civil engineering projects of the same massive scale as turning lakes into land.