4 ms·
Sway Tower, the Tallest Unreinforced Concrete Structure (2020)
- jessriedel 5y ago> Sway Tower was the first building in Britain to be made of non-reinforced concrete Unless I am completely confused, this cannot be true. Concrete has been used since the ancient Romans while iron and steel reinforcements were only really developed in the mid 19th century.
- nkoren 5y ago(Caveat: I'm not truly an expert on Roman concrete, although I love it -- the Pantheon being my favourite building in the whole if human history.) My understanding is that the use of Roman concrete was very highly centralised in and around Rome, and tailed off dramatically towards the outer reaches of the Empire. Indeed I've seen this cited as the key factor in the technology going extinct -- basically, it was very locally endemic. In any case, I'm unaware of any Roman concrete structures having been found in Britain, so this statement may indeed be true.
- iampivot 5y agoWasn't this also because they needed certain volcanic ashes for their concrete, which would be hard to find elsewhere?
- chucksta 5y agoYes, seawater and ash https://unews.utah.edu/roman-concrete/ https://unews.utah.edu/roman-concrete/
- jessriedel 5y agoIt doesn’t have to be Roman concrete. English concretes made with, e.g., Portland cement, predates Sway tower by a hundred years. Obviously, the only version of this claim that could be true is that Sway Tower was the first building in England built exclusively of unreinforced concrete. (There were uncountable buildings built by using unreinforced concrete and stone, e.g., the third Eddystone Lighthouse completed in 1759.) But I’d still find it very surprising that people built structures in England from reinforced concrete for decades without anyone trying to do it without the reinforcement. (“The first home built using reinforced concrete was a servant’s cottage constructed in England by William B. Wilkinson in 1854.”)
- rosetremiere 5y agoWikipedia seems to agree with you: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Concrete#Industrial_era https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Concrete#Industrial_era
- tokai 5y agoIts not that surprising. Even though Romans had concrete, they didn't build many building wholly of concrete. The British Romans did use concrete in their buildings. Especially in floors, walls, and as mortar to bind building elements. But there is no evidence of any Roman building in Britain made with concrete as the primary building material. https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/journal-of-roman-studies/article/abs/notes-on-buildingconstruction-in-roman-britain/16E4A959BE685AEAF9DDC83C9FBA240A https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/journal-of-roman-stu...
- throwaway0a5e 5y agoIn a pre-industrial world concrete doesn't usually pencil out except in the most extreme use cases. You're usually better off mortaring real stone together. In the modern world it makes sense because bulk liquids are fast/efficient/cheap to handle.
- xattt 5y agoIs it called Sway Tower because of instability in wind? Or is it just a name? Edit: I did read the article, but couldn’t tell if the village or the tower was named first.
- pcl 5y agoFrom the article: “On the outskirts of Sway, a village near Lymington, on Britain’s south coast, stands a peculiar Victorian tower.”
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- mnw21cam 5y agoNominative determinism at its best.
- djaychela 5y agoAccording to Wikipedia, it's named in the Doomsday book, so it's been around a lot longer than the tower. [1] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sway,_Hampshire https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sway,_Hampshire
- dan-robertson 5y agoMore pictures can be found online: https://www.greatbritishlife.co.uk/homes-and-gardens/property/a-look-inside-sway-tower-7198946 https://www.greatbritishlife.co.uk/homes-and-gardens/propert... https://www.quirkyaccom.com/the-tower-sway https://www.quirkyaccom.com/the-tower-sway Not really great though
- foobarbecue 5y ago"Andrew Peterson was a good man, and he employed only the unemployed" That's good? Isn't employing the unemployed ... the usual way to employ?
- djaychela 5y agoNo, often people already have jobs and move to a new one. This was seen as a philanthropic act to employ only those who were without work.
- k_sze 5y agoNot necessarily. Most businesses don’t go out of their way to look for unemployed people (e.g. the random beggar at the corner of the street who seems at least physically fit for light manual labour) to employ. If you are physically, mentally, and intellectually fit for any kind of work, yet are neither employed nor actively seeking employment, you’ll usually be shunned by most employers in a capitalist society.
- ojhughes 5y agoExcited to see my local area on HN! The tower is currently for sale, only £2.25 million https://www.rightmove.co.uk/properties/120680285#/?channel=RES_BUY https://www.rightmove.co.uk/properties/120680285#/?channel=R...
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- alephnan 5y agoI found sites specializing in islands and castles in the U.K. They have low price tags, but they likely are liabilities rather than assets.
- Jaruzel 5y agoThis is 100% true. I was recently seriously considering buying a ruined castle to renovate - I could afford to purchase it, but running the numbers to refurb it AND maintain it made it totally impractical. :(
- seiferteric 5y agoTo live in sure, but could you do it as a vacation rental?
- masklinn 5y ago
- alephnan 5y agoSway tower is 218 feet tall. This wooden pagoda is 220 feet. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pagoda_of_Fogong_Temple https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pagoda_of_Fogong_Temple
- ncmncm 5y agoI thought the Sydney Opera House was pretty big... Wikipedia says 213 ft / 65 m; so, only 3 ft short of this one. Odds are SOH will last longer, being less subject to, er, sway. Sway Tower has unique merits, not least being cheaper to buy.
- jbotz 5y agoUnreinforced concrete has its advantages... this tower still stands after 140 years, and so barring an earthquake it can't withstand it is likely to continue to stand for hundreds more years. Steel-reinforced concrete is considered to have a lifespan of 50-150 years... after that the reinforcement rods will have rusted, and in the process the concrete is likely to have cracked (this is called "concrete cancer"). And since these structures were usually designed in ways that depend on the properties of steel-reinforced concrete, that means they become structurally unsound even if they don't outright fall down. Nowadays for projects meant to last people use stainless steel reinforcement or even carbon fiber reinforcement, but these are expensive.