3 ms·
The Librarians Are Not Okay
- meristohm 5y ago"There ain't not sin and there ain't no virtue. There's just stuff people do." -John Steinbeck in The Grapes of Wrath We all have our current set of values. Mine include whole-heartedly supporting a tax-supported public library system in which people with otherwise limited access to resources (and on that point I support increasing such access, as in healthcare, housing, and education, because I care about people I may never meet) have access to so many other worlds via the perspective of authors who have made the effort to share their stories. If we collectively fund the arts we'll have more books from a more-diverse set of authors (which only matters if enough of us value that). If I didn't have parents who read to me every day and who frequently took me to the library (one of the few places I was trusted to be on my own at a young age) I might not have read as broadly or care as much as I do about libraries. Public libraries are refuges of belonging. Along with outdoor spaces they are my favorite places to spend time, by myself and with my child (I'm the primary-care person), who has some disabilities and through books finds commonalities. The librarians recognize us, are kind, welcoming, and helpful, and the cadence of a library visit is delightfully slow (much like being in the woods--so much history and potential). Economically, because of libraries it is likely that I've spent more money on books rather than less, especially when buying gifts for people. I've a lot more to say on the subject (and have commented about libraries here before), but I'll end this by noting that two of my favorite authors, Ray Bradbury and Octavia Butler, credit public libraries with much of their formative education.
- bediger4000 5y agoWe as a free market society shouldn't have publicly owned, or even publicly accessible, libraries. They distort the market for books and other materials, and therefore are illegitimate government interference.
- pmdulaney 5y agoMany years ago I carpooled with a libertarian who believed that we shouldn't have police. Rather, if you want protection you should either protect yourself or subscribe to a security service. He was also opposed to the county public health department assigning grades (A, B, etc.) to restaurants; if you want to subscribe to a service to monitor restaurants, that's your choice. I can't say I agree with my old carpool buddy or with you. But I am a big fan of freedom of speech, so I'm giving you an up vote.
- bediger4000 5y agoOne substantial problem with any "let individuals choose an X service and subscribe to it" as your libertarian friend advocated is economy of scale. Only a loon would say that there isn't economy of scale in almost every situation. In combination with some almost-as-well-established cognitive biases, this means that very few voluntary public health departments would ever exist. I don't see a way around this.
- musicale 5y agoIs there any evidence suggesting that libraries are killing bookstores? If so, is this something we should be concerned about, or do the public benefits of libraries outweigh the reduced opportunities for booksellers? Considering this was apparently the closing keynote at an academic library conference (CALM), is there any reason to believe that school libraries are a bad idea?
- deknos 5y agoYou know, i support that you are able to say that. But i have also the right to say that bit: You are an idiot.
- bediger4000 5y agoSo no substantive counter arguments. I see.
- cafard 5y agoWell, when you have radical socialists like Andrew Carnegie influencing public policy, what can you expect? More seriously, is the "free market" aspect of society the fundamental one that overrides all others?
- TheCoelacanth 5y agoCopyright also distorts the market for books and other materials, so let's get rid of that too.
- bediger4000 5y agoAh, a True Libertarian! Welcome, Citizen! Thank you for your support!