7 ms·
Speedsolving Rubik's Cube: 8355 Method
- reedf1 5y agoWow this looks cool, I learned CFOP as a teenager and from showing it to people the number of algos (150-200+) is definitely the barrier for entry for most. Solving a cube with 3 algos means most people can probably learn in an hour or two.
- ibraheemdev 5y agoYou can follow 2-look OLL/PLL with just a handful of algorithms.
- fouronnes3 5y agoChoosing a speedcubing method is an interesting algorithm design challenge. It's basically a tradeoff between speed and how many subalgorithms sequences you need to learn by heart. On the simplicity extremum there's the corner-3-cycle method, where you can solve it using zero hard coded sequence (pure reasoning). On the speed extremum, there's Fridrich or ZZ, which most top level speedcubers use but they require memorizing hundreds of sequences.
- progbits 5y agoAre there statistics on how many moves people used for record runs? I've only seen them measure the time but from the video recording you could probably get a rough count of moves too. I would love to see the trend lines for those. Are the world records getting faster due to quicker execution of same number of moves, or using fewer moves thanks to better algorithms?
- kuboble 5y agoThere are two main 3x3x3 speedsolving methods. Cfop and roux. 90% of world class solvers use cfop which has significantly higher move count (55 vs 45). The cfop method has characteristics which make it considerably more finger friendly, allows for less regrips and makes look ahead easier which makes up for the extra 10 moves. The world record progression is mostly due to top solvers being able to turn faster with fewer pauses. E.g. the fastest cuber ever Max Park averages less than 6 seconds but his solves are not more sophisticated than those averaging 10s.
- chrisdhal 5y agoI chose Roux specifically so I didn't have to learn a bunch of algorithms. You do obviously have to know a few, but you get to a couple points and while you can use a specific algorithm, you can also basically do the same thing X number of times and it works out and gets you to the next step. CFOP is definitely more finger friendly (no middle layer changes), but I think Roux has fewer regrips, at least at non-speedcube levels (maybe I'm wrong, but I never change the orientation). Roux is also considered more "intuitive", there are points where you can look at the cube and (after a while) just see what needs to be done. I don't do it for speed, so I haven't bothered learning all the algorithms. I'm "fast enough", but I probably only do 10ish solves a day, and Roux makes it really easy to remember the 3-4 algorithms needed to solve that. It still amazes people when you can do it, and even taking 90 seconds to do it, but with hardly any pauses, still makes people think you're a wizard or something.
- phkahler 5y ago>> It still amazes people when you can do it, and even taking 90 seconds to do it, but with hardly any pauses, still makes people think you're a wizard or something. I find this to be quite true. I learned a fairly slow method back in the 80's and can't remember all of the details so I have to figure it out. I don't run across a cube more than say once a year, so it may take 2-3 minutes to solve it. But part of the time I'm doing memorized sequences which allow looking up at a person while solving. You have a little conversation while doing it, and at the end you just put it down like it's not a big deal. The person looks at you not quite sure if there's any significance to what just happened and then you move on as if you were timing your nails or something. It's just a fun little thing to do from time to time.
- loloquwowndueo 5y agoZz is also not unpopular and is “ focused both on low move count and high turning speed”. https://www.speedsolving.com/wiki/index.php/ZZ_method https://www.speedsolving.com/wiki/index.php/ZZ_method
- nsilvestri 5y ago
- reedf1 5y agoAt a high enough level it becomes a numbers game. In CFOP you will occasionally skip whole sequences due to a favourable permutation, a lot of high level cubing is just solving enough cubes that you get these rare and extremely fast permutations in a competition setting.
- falcrist 5y agoParticularly good solvers are able to see potential skips or favorable arrangements and alter their solve to "force" a particular arrangement in a later stage. Preserving an F2L pair during the cross, or choosing a better OLL algorithm during F2L. It's pretty neat to watch breakdowns of solves.
- SnooSux 5y agoMost records have "reconstructed solutions", where people recreate the solution from start to end. You could get the number of moves that way, though I couldn't find a dataset of them. > Are the world records getting faster due to quicker execution of same number of moves, or using fewer moves thanks to better algorithms? My novice understanding is that it's the former. The algorithms haven't changed very much in the past 20 years or so, maybe a few variations that are more ergonomic. After learning all the algs, it's a matter of improving look-ahead (making sure you know what alg to perform next while your current is wrapping up) and otherwise increasing your turns per second (TPS). The records dropped quite drastically a few years back, which is likely coming from advancements in cubing hardware. Adding magnets to prevent overshoot while turning helped people speed up quite a bit.
- charcircuit 5y agoThere is also a difference between knowing a sequence and being able to maintain it and keep execution fast. Two fast ones can be faster than one slow one.
- Waterluvian 5y agoIs there hypothetically a single algorithm I can just repeat indefinitely and eventually get a solved cube? I’m guessing no: you need conditional branches otherwise your single algorithm would just end up back where you started?
- tzs 5y agoYou definitely need conditional branches. Without conditional branches you would be limited to fixed sequences of cube moves. Fixed sequences of cube moves are reversible and they are deterministic. It follows that for any given fixed sequence S there is exactly one starting configuration C such that applying S to C results in a solved cube.
- myaccount80 5y agoIt’s called Devil’s algorithm but I believe it is not know yet whether it exists or not https://getgocube.com/play/devils-number/ https://getgocube.com/play/devils-number/
- 988747 5y agoSomewhat related: I was playing with cube recently, and, starting with solved state, I started doing sequence of two moves that came to my mind: rotate right side down, then the bottom, clockwise. After maybe a 100-150 repetitions (I did not count, just did the moves mindlessly for couple minutes) I went back to solved state. I wonder if there are more such sequences, and how long it takes to go back to original state. The obvious difference from Devil's algorithm was that the 2x2 sub-cube remained untouched the whole time, only the edges were messed up.
- lupire 5y agoEvery sequence behaves this way (For all sequences S, there exists n_S such that S ^ n_S equals S^0, the starting state.) Proving this is an introductory problem in Rubik's theory. Try it!
- zeroonetwothree 5y ago
- thenoblesunfish 5y agoI got a 5x5 cube a while ago and was reading about how to solve it, and came across a nice, concise description of how one might invent moves which can be combined into algorithms which let you make incremental progress on a cube. I can't find it again, now! Some of it was along the lines of (1) Figure out how to do something A to a single layer (while messing up the rest of the cube). (2) Observe that if you do A, then rotate the layer R, then undo A (A'), you have an operation B = A R A' which does something to only one layer of the cube. I assume that most moves in most common algorithms can be expressed in terms of a couple of fundamental techniques like this (probably using the words "commutator" and "conjugate"). Does someone have a link or reference that gives you the general meta-technique (even if it involves incompletely-specified things like "figure out an interesting sequence of moves in terms of their effect on a single layer")? I'm interested in this because I'm not really interested in learning (again) and forgetting (again) any particular existing method for solving the cube, but it would be fun to be able to fiddle around with it in a less-than-random way and eventually arrive at a method, based on some higher-level principles.
- zwegner 5y agoThere's a method entirely based on group theory, a version of the original computer algorithm created to solve the cube (the Thistlewaite algorithm) simplified for use by a human [1]. It iteratively solves the cube into simpler groups that need a smaller moveset to solve (the last step uses only half turns on each face, no quarter turns). It requires only a bit of memorization, and you can understand exactly how the algorithm works. It's not a great speedsolving method, but you can get relatively fast with it: in [2] there's a solve below 30 seconds. [1] https://www.ryanheise.com/cube/human_thistlethwaite_algorithm.html https://www.ryanheise.com/cube/human_thistlethwaite_algorith... [2] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GmjYWYDPhiM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GmjYWYDPhiM
- vvatermelone 5y agohttps://youtu.be/54SGrZbLcoE https://youtu.be/54SGrZbLcoE Not sure if this is exactly what you're looking for, but but it was pretty much the basis for my interest in "big" cubes a few years back.
- 5y ago
- noman-land 5y agoI would just like to point out that Sexy Move is an actually used piece of cuber terminology. https://www.speedsolving.com/wiki/index.php/Sexy_Move https://www.speedsolving.com/wiki/index.php/Sexy_Move
- mauro3 5y agoThis YT-video explains the 8355 method really well https://youtu.be/zB8cKBYNTps https://youtu.be/zB8cKBYNTps . It's how I learned it. They call the sexy-move the fishing-move.