3 ms·
This is a funny comparison to draw, but I don't think it's one with profound meaning: humans have trouble drawing bicycles, but the semantics of a badly-drawn b
by woodruffw 5y ago
This is a funny comparison to draw, but I don't think it's one with profound meaning: humans have trouble drawing bicycles, but the semantics of a badly-drawn bicycle are sound. This is in contrast to DALL-E, which might do an excellent job of drawing apples but otherwise misses the semantics of the query (i.e., "without apples").
In other words: humans mis-draw things because we don't always do a good job of visually apprehending the world; DALL-E mis-draws things because it doesn't really understand the problem statement.
- native_samples 5y agoThe semantics aren't that sound - a lot of the bikes have the seat at the very back, too far from the handlebars.
- woodruffw 5y agoNone of them are good, but the semantics are correct: the seat is behind the handlebars, the handlebars curve correctly, &c. The fact that humans tend to draw the pieces too far apart is more a testament to our problems drawing scale and perspective than a semantic error. (I think this would be apparent if participants were asked to draw a bicycle, followed by a bicycle without a wheel. The two drawings would be roughly as "good" in terms of quality, but the humans will correctly obey the prompt and omit one of the two wheels. I suspect DALL-E would struggle with that prompt.)