5 ms·
I think this article is useful and insightful, but it's missing a big piece that I think is important to emphasize: being woke and looking to others to supply f
by WaxedChewbacca 4y ago
I think this article is useful and insightful, but it's missing a big piece that I think is important to emphasize: being woke and looking to others to supply feelings of validity are kind of the same thing. That's one way to diagnose wokeness.
Genuine feelings of justified self esteem do not come from outside oneself. They come from 1) knowing what is good and 2) living according to one's knowledge of what is good. Another way of saying this is, not only do you need to have a somewhat accurate compass to know which way to go, you also need to actually go the way you know you should go. These things together give you the justified approval of your own conscience, to some degree (incomplete approval because you don't have perfect knowledge of what is good, and you don't do it perfectly anyway because you're not a saint)
The woke fail catastrophically at this kind of stuff. They don't have any deliberate self-cultivation practice that helps them understand what is good. Not knowing what is good, they often err in favor of what feels good at the moment. They have (correct, justified) dislike/disapproval of themselves. They project their badness onto others. When others don't make the same mistake of seeing their own badness in everyone else, the woke mistake themselves for specially enlightened for being able to see the world's badness.
In a way, I think I actually do walk around feeling valid. But the feelings of others are not involved in that estimation. I am a very flawed person, a scruffy wild animal raised by other wild animals, a child raised by children who were themselves raised by children, with no adults in sight no matter how far back one looks, but I have found a process for gradually making myself better, and I am dragging myself down that path for my benefit and everyone else's benefit -- so what else would anyone ask of me? My ability to want the best for others and to do what I know is correct even when no one is looking is steadily growing. I have the justified approval of my own conscience telling me I am OK, no matter what others say.
I don't look to others to tell me I am OK. I don't want their praise. I'm the only one who knows enough to judge, anyway. I will either be happy from living up to my own expectations of myself, or put myself in misery by failing to do that. It is up to me alone.
What kind of self-improvement process am I talking about? Stuff like prayer and meditation. It doesn't matter what it's called, as long as you're gradually training your neurons and synapses and whatever other brain stuff to be more kind, compassionate, joyful in the well being of others, equanimous, generous, grateful, etc. There were good reasons to dislike religion, but I think at this point we have to wonder if we didn't throw out the baby with the bathwater when we discarded religion. The woke may serve to remind us that religion, despite its flaws, was providing great benefit.
Here's how I like to practice:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JCiVBvptZyk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JCiVBvptZyk
https://library.dhammasukha.org/uploads/1/2/8/6/12865490/the_path_to_nibbana__d_johnson_f18.pdf https://library.dhammasukha.org/uploads/1/2/8/6/12865490/the...
- karmakaze 4y agoI can't believe I came to write this and someone else had the same viewpoint, and well said I'll add. I don't know how, but I'd mostly grown up not caring what others are doing and doing 'my own thing'. Even in many circumstances when I look back and think 'a normal kid would have been embarrassed or mortified' I just rolled with it, all the while thinking I was normal. Later in life, I did ponder it and distilled it down to (a) identify my value system (b) do well by that value system (c) be open to updating my value system (d) take feedback in the context of our value systems--sometimes the feedback doesn't apply (e) try to imagine if the value system you die with is one you'll be okay with. Don't tell me 'I'm wrong' tell me how: I want to know if my actions are not aligned with my value system, or if my value system in use conflicts with deeply held or other chosen positions. If our value systems don't overlap sufficiently, we'll have to agree to disagree to the original point. It's like always viewing your future as a 'gradient ascent' and your past for analysis not judgement. Make the best you can of where you find yourself. I also feel very fortunate for the circumstances I found myself in, imagining that 'I' could have been any other person. The one thing I should feel bad about, much more frequently than I do, is not doing enough. I can sometimes be a workaholic, but with personal time I can be a couch potato when I know that I can be much more fit or social.