3 ms·
The flaws you point out are largely a case of the science news cycle in action (https://phdcomics.com/comics.php?f=1174 https://phdcomics.com/comics.php?f=1174)
by lolinder 5y ago
The flaws you point out are largely a case of the science news cycle in action (https://phdcomics.com/comics.php?f=1174 https://phdcomics.com/comics.php?f=1174), not the fault of the researchers. In their actual paper[0] and in the quotes the BBC uses, they don't use the word "vegetarian", and don't really make any unreasonable claims about their findings.
[0] https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/anglo-saxon-england/article/food-and-power-in-early-medieval-england-a-lack-of-isotopic-enrichment/46263E5BB81F455CD873220C0B7601B9 https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/anglo-saxon-england/...
- thaumasiotes 5y agoThe paper is focused on the question of whether the word feorm in a particular historical context refers to a "pure" in-kind taxation of food, from which the king's ordinary diet is sourced, or whether it refers to a special event, separate from the king's ordinary diet. There's no real problem with that. But the BBC says this: > Cambridge University researchers analysed more than 2,000 skeletons and found elites ate no more meat than other social groups. And this is not reasonable at all. Historical sources everywhere in the world are happy to tell us, over and over again, that one of the primary benefits of having money is that you can eat more meat. It is not credible that early medieval England could somehow have been an exception to this; to the extent that the study's methodology indicated that "elites ate no more meat than other social groups", that should be viewed as a fault in the methodology.
- t-3 5y agoAre your historical sources describing similar societies, or is the only similarity the "historical" part? Also, meat is often divided into more preferential portions and less, fresh vs. preserved, and legal vs. illegal. Plenty of room for social stratification without significant quantity differences.