3 ms·
This headline is very misleading. "Study finds Anglo-Saxon kings ate less meat than previously thought" or "kings didn't eat more meat than peasants" would be b
by lolinder 5y ago
This headline is very misleading. "Study finds Anglo-Saxon kings ate less meat than previously thought" or "kings didn't eat more meat than peasants" would be better.
> "We should imagine a wide range of people livening up bread with small quantities of meat and cheese, or eating pottages of leeks and whole grains with a little meat thrown in."
This isn't a "mostly vegetarian" diet as most people would understand "vegetarian".
- qiskit 5y ago> This headline is very misleading. Intentionally so. That's the most worrisome part. > This isn't a "mostly vegetarian" diet as most people would understand "vegetarian". Amazing how they turned, "anglo-saxon kings ate a human diet ( meat, dairy, vegetables, grains, fruits, etc )" into "anglo-saxon kings ate a mostly vegetarian diet". I admit I'm not a fan of the bbc, but if they are willing to be this misleading about vegetarian diets, how misleading are they on other stories.
- thablackbull 5y agoQuite a lot actually. > The BBC misrepresented my views this morning, and I admit I'm stunned. [...] I spent three years doing field research on that myth and wrote an Oxford University Press book debunking it. [1] [1] http://www.chinaafricarealstory.com/2021/12/bbc-misrepresents-my-views-on-debt-trap.html http://www.chinaafricarealstory.com/2021/12/bbc-misrepresent...
- ALittleLight 5y agoIn high school an essay was returned to me with a word I had used, "probably", struck out in red. I went to ask the teacher about it and she told me that I should not use the word "probably" when writing as it did not sound confident. My writing would be better without the word. I reread the sentence and it did sound more assertive and direct without "probably." I then asked my teacher what I should write if I meant to convey that something was probably true, but that I actually wasn't certain or all that confident about it. She was stumped. I can easily see how advice like that leads to "reporting" like this. Some editor goes "Hey, cut this segment, we can't use this, it's confusing, and the story will sound better without it." The author's postscript, where he seems to forgive the BBC, is also pretty bad. Imagine what the editor will learn - "I edited a story to make it clearer and punchier. The expert complained, but the complaint went away when we said 'Sorry'. " If the editor realizes he inverted the meaning of his expert and completely got away with it - well, that will be a counter-productive lesson from the standpoint of accuracy in news. The news has the incentive to be interesting, simple, engaging - all that. None of this nuance stuff. If editors get carte blanche for being new... I don't think that even a new editor should have trouble with the concept of "Don't invert what your expert says."
- bumbledraven 5y ago> I then asked my teacher what I should write if I meant to convey that something was probably true, but that I actually wasn't certain or all that confident about it. Not for school papers, but how about: "I guess [something]."
- ALittleLight 5y agoI think the right choice is to quantify or bound what you mean. "The chance of X is 52%" sounds pretty confident and assertive. If you can't be that precise, then "For reasons X, Y, and Z this is likely, though not certain." I think "probably" is completely fine though.
- mr_toad 5y agoThe title of the paper is “Food and Power in Early Medieval England: Rethinking Feorm”, and the abstract doesn’t mention vegetarianism. https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/anglo-saxon-england/article/food-and-power-in-early-medieval-england-rethinking-feorm/92CCDA9706D8F0858B0DE4CB4D51FB72 https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/anglo-saxon-england/... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Food_render https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Food_render
- lolinder 5y agoYes. There's a companion article which does mention vegetarians, but in the modern context (samples used for comparison): https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/anglo-saxon-england/article/food-and-power-in-early-medieval-england-a-lack-of-isotopic-enrichment/46263E5BB81F455CD873220C0B7601B9 https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/anglo-saxon-england/...
- actually_a_dog 5y agoIn what way does a diet that has "small quantities of meat" not seem "mostly vegetarian?"
- naniwaduni 5y agoIs a diet that contains a small quantity of ricin mostly nontoxic?
- akvadrako 5y agoVegetarians don't eat meat. A meal that's 95% vegetables/grains but 5% meat is 0% vegetarian.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- throw_m239339 5y agoThe title is misleading on purpose. I consider this straight out misinformation from the BBC, they are misrepresenting what a study says, for clickbait reasons.