I think it’s a leap to go from “this person is disciplined in their personal appearance” to “this person is disciplined in XYZ” or “this person is disciplined i

I think it’s a leap to go from “this person is disciplined in their personal appearance” to “this person is disciplined in XYZ” or “this person is disciplined in general”. It’s a classic case of the halo effect. If you had an electrical issue, you wouldn’t contact your doctor because they are good at figuring things out and pretty smart. Domain specific skills and habits are just that.