4 ms·
I develop apps for both iPhone and Android. I stopped carrying my iPhone for personal use, and use my Droid Bionic full time. Here are the 3 reasons why. 1.
by unoti 15y ago
I develop apps for both iPhone and Android. I stopped carrying my iPhone for personal use, and use my Droid Bionic full time. Here are the 3 reasons why.
1. Google Maps, and navigation. If you're actually driving places, google maps is an amazing godsend. If you're taking mass transit, it blows the doors off what's on the iPhone. Ever get on a bus with your iphone, and have it vibrate
in your pants when the next bus stop is the one you need to take? Google navigate shows you your mass transit trip in a schematic view that shows you where all the stops are in list form, and animates the little bullet point in the list as you move between stops. It's breathtaking. It'll be hard
to beat Google Maps on an iphone, and I missed this sorely. For me the maps
are so superior that during the brief time that I used iPhone, I used it as a
wireless hotspot and kept my old android phone around just for the maps
and navigation. I'm new to my city (San Francisco) and my whole experience
of moving here was greatly enriched by the awesomeness of Google Maps.
Many people probably already know where they're going or are already
familiar with their mass transit options, so using a second class citizen for
navigation (such as the iPhone) is probably fine for them.
2. Google Mail. Google's gmail app UI is awesome. I didn't know how much I
loved it until I had to use iOS for a while. Bundling things by conversation
is great. And I often receive 20-30 emails that are all divided into a total of
about 3 conversations. Google lets me read and archive or delete those
in 4 clicks (3 checkboxes for the 3 conversations, then one click of Archive
or Delete). The iOS mail app makes me do that in around 60-80 clicks:
either a swipe on the index page followed by a delete, or else a click on each
email, followed by a delete.
3. Notification bar. I can always look at the top bar of my droid and know
what, if anything, needs my attention. Or at the very least, why my phone
made a noise in the last few minutes. It was hard for me to see at a glance what things just caused
my phone to beep. If I received a meeting reminder, and a text, and something else,
it was always clear on my droid which things need my attention, because of the status bar.
There wasn't something like this on the iPhone. A few days ago they implemented a
status bar on the iPhone, but it still feels like a cheap immitation of what Android does,
in much the same way that the author here talks about how Android is a cheap clone of iOS.
But to be clear, the "feel" of the iPhone is superior in pretty much every way. But to me, it's not all about feel.
- Geee 15y agoThat's why I'm getting the N9. Better 'feel' and UX than iOS, more open than Android. Best navigation and integrated messaging with GTalk, Skype etc. Real-time event view to everything wins widgets hands-down. No need to jump loops to do simple things, no need to open apps to check updates etc. Personally I can live with fewer apps if everyday tasks are handled so well.
- aurynn 15y agoThis is why I bought the N9. It's damn slick, in every one of these facets. Though, syncing is still a major pain point.
- 2muchcoffeeman 15y agoI got a Nexus S for the same reason the author did. To address your points. 1. Good luck using those features with rubbish GPS hardware. I've tried testing my Nexus S navigation on public transport and mostly it looks for GPS signals. My iPhone 4 picks up a signal fine. I agree they would be awesome features. But Android has just added 'research GPS hardware' to the list of things you need to do to get an Android handset. 2. I can't get over the fact that the forward button actually goes backwards in your list and the back button actually goes forwards. But the conversation feature is good. iOS 5 has better mail. 3. It is pretty handy. iOS 5 still does not tell you that there are pending alerts. You get the first notification and then that's it. You have to check or swipe through screen to look for those little red circles.
- anigbrowl 15y ago1. Is the problem with the phone or Android? I'm still using a Nexus One and rely heavily on the navigation features because I hate asking people for directions. I usually get a fix within 1-2 seconds of turning the phone on.
- thwarted 15y ago2. I can't get over the fact that the forward button actually goes backwards in your list and the back button actually goes forwards. I wonder if this has to do with the displayed sort order. I don't know which one you mean when you say "back" and "forward", but the button with the arrow pointing to the left on the message/thread view screen on my Android 2.3.6 nexus S gmail app goes to the message further toward the top of the list, and the button with the arrow pointing to the right goes to the message further down the list. This is as I expect.