4 ms·
I recently went the other way around. After exchanging my Galaxy Tab 2 times for random hangs and unexplained slowness I thought I will check out the iPad. I st
by blinkingled 15y ago
I recently went the other way around. After exchanging my Galaxy Tab 2 times for random hangs and unexplained slowness I thought I will check out the iPad. I still have an Android phone that I am perfectly happy with so throughout the day I go back and forth with iOS and Android.
The experience on the iPad is undeniably superior after iOS5. The UI is way smoother than Honeycombs, I haven't found any beta behavior yet.
BUT, usability wise I find iPad to be incredibly annoying and limited. I keep looking for the back button and I am yet to find the level of consistency that people claim is hallmark of iOS.
Few examples -
1) Music Player UI is inconsistent with other apps - no navigation button at top left, it doesnt cover the 'desktop' fully for reasons I don't understand. Search field is at bottom right - considering it is commonly used it should be easy to locate and access.
2) Notifications - while they are lot better with 5.0, it is still inconsistent. I still see the old modal notifications from built in apps like email - twice now I saw old interrupting notifications from exchange mail - one was on Sunday evening for a meeting request on Wednesday! Oh and the notification bar doesn't cover the full screen when pulled down on the iPad unlike iPhone.
3) Always having to hit the physical home button for app switching is annoying compared to Android
4) You cannot subscribe to a podcast using the iPad on its own! I spent 30 minutes trying to do just that. It's not PC free, yet!
5) Background apps and notifications are flaky - Vtok for example was inexplicably killed some times. And when it wasn't it did not notify me using the new notification system.
6) Google integration is poor but this part I was fully expecting.
7) Finally I found that I was still confronted with iPhone only apps that looked horrible when run on iPad. This sort of thing works way better in Google land.
But I am forced to keep it until Google and co get their act together on the tablet side. Right now the user experience on the best Android tablet is way shoddy compared to the iPad but if Google could get that fixed I am fairly certain there will be compelling reasons to switch back.
- woobar 15y ago2) this is configurable, i.e. you can choose what apps should use modal alert, banners on top or nothing. 3) you can try 'four-fingers' gestures as a replacement. They are useless on an iPhone, bu on iPad they make Home button obsolete.
- blinkingled 15y ago#2 - Yep, for some reason calendar was set to Alert. Thanks.
- cormullion 15y ago> 3) Always having to hit the physical home button for app switching is annoying compared to Android There's a four-finger slide for switching apps on the iPad... It may need enabling, though. The four fingers don't have to be spread out - just together is fine.
- blinkingled 15y agoThanks, it is a lot better than home button. Did not have to enable anything. 5 finger in-swipe goes to desktop, out-swipe brings up multitasking bar and 4 finger switches apps - albeit without preview so that's still a bit annoying.
- hack_edu 15y agoReally though, the home button design is really showing its age... Look how much screen real estate it takes up on the iPhone, or how much of the iPad's frame could be utilized if there were soft keys. Its become the first thing I notice whenever I pick up my iPad. Just a big ol' ugly button.
- saturdaysaint 15y ago4) There are some great iOS podcast apps. I use Instacast, which does everything you'd want (allows searching, subscribing, streaming, downloading, etc.).
- blinkingled 15y agoYeah I came across it but it seems to be an iPhone app. Any suggestions for iPad? Doggcatcher was superb on Android side.