5 ms·
Robocadey: Shitposting as a Service
- JetAlone 5y ago"What is art? Art is when you challenge the assumptions that people make about a medium and use that conflict to help them change what they think about that medium." I think the above definition, perhaps unwittingly, robs us of traditional value in art. By that above definition, a classical greco-roman statue that doesn't challenge anyone's ideas or perception cannot be art. I am not very interested in communicating with anyone who doesn't sooner or later realize how preposterous it is to say "your work doesn't challenge anyone's assumptions, so it can't be art". It's a self-defeater because at some point the unchallenged assumption that art challenges assumptions must itself be challenged in order to produce any more art. I think the below definition is good, maybe better but also not perfect because of its insistence on beauty alone. "The conscious use of the imagination in the production of objects intended to be contemplated or appreciated as beautiful, as in the arrangement of forms, sounds, or words." The definition for "object". I prefer the word "pattern" where any physical object is matter arranged in a certain pattern. "Something perceptible by one or more of the senses, especially by vision or touch; a material thing." Here's my pitch for an improved definition of art: "The conscious use of the imagination in the production or recognition of patterns intended to be contemplated or appreciated as beautiful or thought-provoking such as in the arrangement of forms, sounds, or words." I am going to include the author likes to call art as art, because it is. I am going to exclude anything without a conscious intention of creativity in patterns. You are not making art unless you intend to. You may retroactively call something you did subconsciously "art". When you do that the conscious creation is your identification and naming of the pattern you noted, through logos; that is, the power of the mind, and language. In this way, even pointing at a mountain can be seen as a kind of performance art. The way you pointed to it at that moment, if you call attention to it as art, that is your art of being and communicating. The distant mountain was one of your artistic ingredients, so was your finger. What the writer has helpfully noticed is that art seems to be elusive; doesn't easily allow its definition to be pinned down, but it has a concrete existence in part of who we are. It cannot really exist without this thing we call "consciousness".
- bitwize 5y ago> I think the above definition, perhaps unwittingly, robs us of traditional value in art. By that above definition, a classical greco-roman statue that doesn't challenge anyone's ideas or perception cannot be art. It was art in its day, but a modern sculptor creating Greco-Roman statuary is less an artist than Marcel Duchamp exhibiting an upside down urinal, because the act of exhibiting the urinal as art calls into question the unconscious assumptions about what art should look like. Right? Reiterating the values that came before is conservatism; and conservatism is the death of art because there's no thinking involved. Art must therefore force its audience to think in order to qualify. You are using a definition of art that hasn't been conventionally accepted ever since Duchamp, who once said that art is that which challenges the notion of what is art (so, pretty much Xe's definition). Duchamp also said "Art is either plagiarism or revolution". So unless you are doing Greco-Roman statuary in a manner that shatters people's expectations of Greco-Roman statuary, your statues are a jejune copy of what has come before -- and therefore not art. Capisce?
- yakubin 5y agoWas Leonardo da Vinci not an artist when he drew the Vitruvian Man? Were all Renaissance sculptors and painters for that matter not artists, since they were copying the Greco-Roman style? Are script-writers of House of Cards not artists due to writing a Shakespearean play? Is George Lucas not an artist because he did not make anyone question what art is? > Duchamp also said "Art is either plagiarism or revolution". So unless you are doing Greco-Roman statuary in a manner that shatters people's expectations of Greco-Roman statuary, your statues are a jejune copy of what has come before -- and therefore not art. Here is a contradiction. First plagiarism is listed as an example of art, to then be described as "not art". Also, I think that art which sticks to established understanding of what art is isn't necessarily plagiarism. Just because there were plenty of standard 3-act structured plays/films, does not mean that subsequent attempts are plagiaristic. Otherwise art would be castrated to just form, when in fact it is a marriage of form and substance. I think this fixation on "subverting expectations" comes from self-centredness of some artists. Maybe if you dedicate your whole life to just art, you don't have other experiences to draw from to create something about more than art itself. And so art becomes a simulacrum.
- ljp_206 5y agoI created a clunky discord bot that listens to everything my friends and I say on discord and uses that data in Markov chains to talk to us. The bot has various random chance parameters that allow it to chat with us, reply to us, send us memes (that it also generates via the imgflip api), choose random outcomes, and more. This bot has become quite the character and art project. He entertains, horrifies, and banters with us, mostly in terribly broken discordese that gives a laugh out of goofiness. My brother also took a bit of time to hook him up to one of the GPTs, producing even more outlandish, essay-like responses. I highly recommend coding toys like this for one's self and/or friends.
- numlock86 5y agoSounds like a gold mine for r/shitposting's automod responses.
- robotnikman 5y agoI did something similar with a bot for my Minecraft server many years ago as a fun project, using markov chains as well (this was well before GPT). It certainly said some interesting things
- noizejoy 5y agoTo my sensibilities, the kind of thing described in the OP might be more craft than art.
- xena 5y agoI'm the artist of this public abstract art installation if you have any questions. Here's a few pre-answered questions that may come up: > why not GPT-3? I can't run GPT-3 locally on my homelab. I also wanted to use GPT-2 _specifically_ because its responses are not totally human. This helps put it in the uncanny valley much like /r/SubredditSimulatorGPT2. > why do this at all? Science isn't about "why?". It's about "why not?". Artistic expression like this is much in the same way.