3 ms·
Shorter answer, with simpler vocabulary: The Earth is basically a solid hunk of rock, with a core of dense metals like iron. Solid rock and iron just don't co
by bell-cot 5y ago
Shorter answer, with simpler vocabulary:
The Earth is basically a solid hunk of rock, with a core of dense metals like iron. Solid rock and iron just don't collapse under pressures or temperatures that are even slightly sane. (Unless they are hollow, have an empty space under them, or are falling down into something less dense - like an undersea landslide does.) Sure, the pressures and temperatures in the middle of the Earth are high - but we're pretty much talking pressures that some C-list college physics lab could maintain for days on end, and temperatures lower than an old arc welder you can buy on eBay could do forever.
Stars that actually collapse - not just cool off, shrink, and fade away - have pressures and temperatures inside that are a million miles from sane. We're talking "a hundred-billion dollar atom smasher, that is 15 miles wide, could do that - but only to a speck of dust, and for a trillionth of a second". Vs. a star that is about to collapse has had millions of cubic miles of stuff under those pressures and temperatures, for years.
Under those sorts of conditions, atoms get smashed. Really smashed. We're talking the difference between taking a box of packing peanuts and lightly patting 'em down (inside the Earth), and putting that box of packing peanuts into a big stamping press in a steel mill (inside the collapsing star).
- atty 5y agoThe statement about particle colliders is not really correct. The relativistic heavy ion collider, where I used to work, is about 2.4 miles in circumference, and reaches temperatures in the 10s of trillions of degrees in its collisions. This is > 1000 times hotter than a supernova. The environment in these collisions is made to reproduce the state of the universe fractions of a second after the Big Bang, and aren’t really comparable to any normal stellar activity.
- bell-cot 5y agoAny thought on what sort of hardware would actually be necessary to reproduce the temperatures / pressures / densities of a sleepy little 1.4 solar mass red supergiant pre-supernova iron core, for a full 10e-12 seconds, in the full volume of a visible speck of dust? (At least in Wikipedia's version of things, the temperature inside a nice, fresh hot-off-the-Collapse'O'Matic-grill neutron star is "from around 10e11 to 10e12 kelvins". Not quite your comfort zone, but far closer:)