3 ms·
That is what I hated about the article. No companies shouldn't be doing this to their staff. It is bad for business. But that the same time I want the governme
by tomjen3 15y ago
That is what I hated about the article. No companies shouldn't be doing this to their staff. It is bad for business.
But that the same time I want the government to be forced to undergo not just this level of scruteny but a far harsher one. Why? Because I am forced to pay for it so they damn better work hard for it.
- dredmorbius 15y agoAnd if the cost of that micromanagement is 10x the value derived from it? Cut your nose to spite your face much?
- quanticle 15y agoIt's a question of benefits vs. costs. Yeah, retailers could eliminate shoplifting if they really wanted to. But, to do so, they'd have to turn their stores into prisons, with full cavity searches at the exits. This is obviously bad for business, so most retailers accept a certain level of shoplifting and aggressively prosecute the shoplifters they do catch. The problem is that with government, there is no mechanism for assessing whether the costs of a regulation are outweighed by its benefits. What good does banning biscuits at company meetings do? Yes, you've saved 200 thousand odd pounds sterling, but what has it cost you? More importantly, what's the accumulated costs of all of these little regulations. Individually, they don't sound like much, but if you get enough of them, they really start to drag on productivity. What's worse, the impact of these regulations tends to be non-linear. Something as little as "no more free pop at all hands meetings" can lead to an exodus of talent if it happens to be the last straw, as it were. EDIT: Joel Spolsky had a very nice column on this, but I can't find it at the moment.
- DanBC 15y agoNot only is there a loss of morale but you need to employ people to do the scrutinising, and then set up systems to gather evidence. Preventing someone over-claiming on biscuits and gasoline / petrol milage just added lots to cost and made people unhappy. See also (again in the UK) the many people entitled to some benefits who do not claim those. I believe (but have no evidence) that part of the reason is the vigorous scrutiny that people go through. This doesn't stop criminal gangs from making large sums of money from benefit fraud.
- nobody314159 15y agoThat's why many companies have flat expenses rates for executives. The day rate is $XXX in Europe, $YYY in USA and $ZZZ in Japan, there are tables of relative cost available. If you want to stay in a cheaper hotel/with friends/use your airmiles you keep the money, if you want to spend extra and stay in a nicer hotel - eat at fancier restaurants - fine you pay the extra yourself.
- anigbrowl 15y agoAuditors and management consultants tend to cost a lot more than snacks.
- cromulent 15y agoI did a lot of consulting for a very large automotive firm about 10 years ago. I turned up at one meeting and every invitee had arrived, unusually. Then - lattes, cappuccinos, and sandwiches arrived! Gleefully, they told me: because you're here, we get to order coffee and food. They also had a new rule about "no food for internals only". As all economists know, people respond to incentives. You invite externals, you get free food|coffee|biscuits. Design your incentives very carefully.
- nobody314159 15y agoI work in a government funded university. I had to travel to London as an adviser to a day of government meetings. Fair enough the government ultimately pay me. I did however make the mistake of buying a coffee and a burger at the station on the way back! My entire expenses claim was denied (train/taxi/etc) because a lunch had been provided and the meeting was only one day and so only one meal could be claimed for. Eventually after much back and forth the govt dept sent someone to my university to 'explain things to me'. I can claim for one meal - but it didn't matter how much it cost! I could have claimed for a 12course banquet at the Ritz, but I couldn't claim for two separate slices of pizza - because that was two meals.