2 ms·
> And if the rule is "don't juggle forks while riding a unicycle around electrical outlets", it's usually because someone lied about what happened. > This is a
by thaumasiotes 5y ago
> And if the rule is "don't juggle forks while riding a unicycle around electrical outlets", it's usually because someone lied about what happened.
> This is a description of a rape, and the person who committed it came up with a story to explain it away, and the Talmud has codified this excuse as justifying a modest penalty
This conclusion is unwarranted. This is a description of a sex act which the parties were not willing to admit to. But nothing about the story indicates that it's a rape. If consensual sex between the man and the woman would be forbidden by the local culture, it has just as much need to be explained away as a rape would.
(And since in this case the woman's shame is public -- and explicitly commented on in the ruling -- the woman wouldn't have much to lose by contradicting her rapist's account of falling off a roof.)
- AaronFriel 5y ago> the woman wouldn't have much to lose by contradicting her rapist's account of falling off a roof Hello there, interesting that you say that. What's it like in a different universe where women have always been able to safely point out an abuser?