4 ms·
Why does redit leave this anti-social loophole exploit open? Is it good for engagement? Seems like a win for the trolls and a net loss in terms of QoL for the
by metadat 5y ago
Why does redit leave this anti-social loophole exploit open? Is it good for engagement? Seems like a win for the trolls and a net loss in terms of QoL for the good actors.
- not2b 5y agoBlocking is sometimes necessary when someone is behaving as an abusive troll, or switches from normal conversation to hurling personal abuse. Yes, it can be abused by people who think that having the last word is "winning". One way to address that might be to add "Fred blocked Sam" to a thread in which both Fred and Sam previously posted, so everyone knows what happened.
- MrStonedOne 5y ago
- XorNot 5y agoThe downvotes on this comment (at least at the moment) are astounding.
- sacrosancty 5y agoHow about only a silent mute but no block? Then you can protect yourself if you don't want to see it, but to use it as a weapon, you have to convince them you've really muted them - and they might not believe you, so it's weaker. Just like old Usenet and mailing list's *PLONK* message.
- strix_varius 5y agoThe feature is more commonly abused (on reddit) as an aggressive tactic by abusers. The person being "blocked" tends to be the target of abuse. This is because of some really bizarre oversights in how the feature was implemented: Once you have been blocked, you cannot block back (because reddit no longer shows the user who blocked you as existing, while you're logged in). So if you want to harass someone, the best thing to do is to create an account and block them immediately. Not only can a blocked person not respond to a blocker's comment or post, but they also cannot respond to any descendent of said post. Thus, on a small subreddit, or on popular posts in a large one, it's possible for a blocking peer to essentially "ban" you from the conversation at large. By repeating this technique in the same subreddit, it's possible to gradually manufacture false consensus by preemptively silencing folks who would disagree with you. This user did an excellent study/proof when the new feature was launched: https://www.reddit.com/r/TheoryOfReddit/comments/sdcsx3/testing_reddits_new_block_feature_and_its_effects/ https://www.reddit.com/r/TheoryOfReddit/comments/sdcsx3/test...
- root_axis 5y agoIt's not a "loophole exploit", reddit simply gives the user arbitrary control of who they want to block.
- bduerst 5y agoIt used to be Reddit would let users block trolls, and then the user would never have to deal with seeing the troll posts ever again, even if they continued to reply. The new way - blocking someone and restricting that person's ability to reply - is an aggressive UX.
- ByteJockey 5y agoBlocking could be filtering out the replies rather than preventing a reply.
- strix_varius 5y agoI would argue that it is, in fact, an exploit. Here's a proof in the wild: https://www.reddit.com/r/TheoryOfReddit/comments/sdcsx3/testing_reddits_new_block_feature_and_its_effects/ https://www.reddit.com/r/TheoryOfReddit/comments/sdcsx3/test...
- harshreality 5y agoBlocking is fine. Nobody should be forced to read anyone else's comments. However, if a block also prevents the blocked person from replying to the blocker's replies, that creates terrible incentives for abuse. Whoever implemented it was only thinking about blocks used against genuine bad actors, with disregard to how blocks could be (and empirically are) used by bad actors. The same thing happens all the time on Twitter, which implemented the same "feature". As strix_varius pointed out in a parallel subthread, this creates a perception of false consensus. It may be, more than any other thing, what's contributed to the hyper-politicization of those platforms. The platforms themselves enforce that any sufficiently engaged user, through enough defensive and offensive blocking, will end up in an echo chamber.
- rectang 5y agoAllowing people to decide who they're going to engage with is freedom of association. Platforms which allow unlimited brigading prevent unpopular subcommunities from holding conversations amongst themselves. Hyper-polarization is not diminished when those who disapprove of a community descend en masse to interject and disrupt. Platforms which don't allow subcommunities to wall themselves off degrade the ability of those subcommunities to use the platform, and if the volume of disruptive posts is high enough, essentially deny them use of the platform by allowing them to be shouted down. This applies no matter who the subcommunities are or what politics they espouse.
- Helloyello 5y ago