3 ms·
Okay, so about "cool URIs don't change".¹ 20 years ago I accepted this as obvious truth. Now I'm less sure. URIs used to be like phone numbers, in that they we
by CharlesW 5y ago
Okay, so about "cool URIs don't change".¹ 20 years ago I accepted this as obvious truth. Now I'm less sure.
URIs used to be like phone numbers, in that they were designed for humans — today, they're designed for SEO. But today, nobody memorizes phone numbers — people depend on their phone's Contacts app. Similarly, nobody remembers URIs beyond the domain name — they depend on bookmarks, browser history auto-complete, app-specific search functionality, and search engines.
Podcast feed URIs change all the time (old feed URIs redirect to new) and zero people know or care. I believe the same is generally true for web pages.
Playing devil's advocate to myself, AFAIK no browser automatically updates bookmarks even in the face of permanent redirects. They should, right?
¹https://www.w3.org/Provider/Style/URI https://www.w3.org/Provider/Style/URI
- connordoner 5y agoOn that devil’s advocate, I think the flaw in your thought is that many web developers haven’t implemented permanent vs temporary properly…
- at_a_remove 5y agoIt was a quasi-workable sentiment when "webmasters" were operating in arcane BOFH mode. But now, Bob from marketing needs that dumb-ass vanity URL and sure it will displace the dumb-ass vanity URL Cindy needed two years ago. Administration has encroached that far. Sure, for a permanent architecture where we are putting information on the web to slowly accumulate human knowledge, it is a great idea. It dissolves like wedding cake decorations in a church fire under the power of Marketing.
- simonw 5y agoCool URLs not changing isn't about people memorizing them or even really about personal bookmarks: it's about links. Accumulating links to and from your content over the course of many years isn't just valuable because of SEO, it's valuable because you're helping to build a legacy of interlinked content. And that's a cool thing to contribute to!
- Spivak 5y agoSure but hotlinking I don’t think makes sense anymore. Every link will eventually die so the only way to really ensure that links live as long as the content that they point to is to host a copy yourself.
- CharlesW 5y ago> Cool URLs not changing isn't about people memorizing them or even really about personal bookmarks: it's about links. This seems to support my point so I must be misunderstanding it. If a link continues to work because of a redirect, who cares if the URI changes?
- detaro 5y agoIf the link still works it didn't change in that sense. Redirects are totally fine and a way of implementing "Cool URLs don't change". Having redirects doesn't invalidate the principle.
- langsoul-com 5y agoThere's probably an extension that would automatically rename permanent redirects. It would not make sense if a bookmark could randomly change.
- CharlesW 5y ago> It would not make sense if a bookmark could randomly change. Ah, my preference is the opposite — if I have to constantly babysit bookmarks for 301 redirects, that's technically correct but fails the "job to be done" of it.