3 ms·

Broker level stock halts happen all the time too, it was an option. Robinhood has conflicts of interest that don't require meme stock myths. The collateral req

Broker level stock halts happen all the time too, it was an option. Robinhood has conflicts of interest that don't require meme stock myths. The collateral requirements was from DTCC which affected many brokers and Robinhood simply got all the attention and is unrelated to Robinhood's conflict of interest, doesnt that prove I'm not subscribing to the conspiracies? The conflict of interest is that Citadel is their primary customer who gets all the trade data from robinhood's user. Citadel infused capital into Melvin which was the main fund Robinhood's users were trying to target because of Melvin's short position in Gamestop. The shadowy cabal conversation never needs to occur. Robinhood reacted to the DTCC collateral requirements, they should have reacted to their users as well, having a little drop of emotional intelligence to say "oh yeah this is reason to do a stock halt" instead of an asymmetric one.

dragontamer 4y ago
You'll have to forgive me, but my opinion of the cabal of GME-pumpers hyping the hell out of the stock on Reddit/WallStreetBets is not a group of conspirators I have much faith in. They create a boogieman who doesn't exist ("The big banks") without actually defining who the hell they are. All the while, they're literally conspiring to Gamma Squeeze the stock up to $1000. Then they get mad at their crappy brokerage for being crap. (I mean... maybe Robinhood shouldn't have been crap. But everyone knew it was a subpar brokerage built on hype and plenty of SEC complaints before the GME-event of January 2021). Then one of them named Roaring Kitty gets incredibly rich from the whole situation, sells off a huge chunk of their stocks, goes quiet for a while and apparently is the good guy. A few days in Congressional hearings later, it becomes blatantly obvious that no one knows what they're talking about and here we are now today. ------ I absolutely see a group of conspirators here. And its not "the big banks". I'm not sure what the legality of the whole exercise was (apparently it was legal?), but I'm not exactly seeing much altruism on the "buy buy buy" crowd. And no. Buying a terribly priced stock when everyone else is buying it isn't "saving the stock market". Its just rocking the boat and pumping the stock price higher. If that's what people want to do with their money that's their business, but don't pretend its some kind of noble effort. I'm not necessarily going to call the /r/WSB group "evil". But they're certainly not "good" either. And their obsession with finding boogiemen to yell at is dangerous mob-like rhetoric. ------ I get that it was a big social event, that large crowds moved and coordinated together, and they all felt very fun to the participants. But guess what? So was the Anti-COVID19 Trucker Convoy as well as Occupy Wall Street. It was a spontaneous mob, coordinated thanks to modern social media. That's all I see the event as honestly. It did some weird and interesting things to some smaller scale brokerages who couldn't handle the buy/sell orders, and it taught me a few things about the nature of exchanges and brokerages. But it wasn't some kind of altruistic event or heroic effort. Thanks to modern social media, I expect these spontaneous crowds to erupt into other forms and other locations... be it online or in meatspace (as per "Twitter Flash Mobs", which were probably their prototype when Social Media was younger). Maybe it was your first spontaneous internet mob, but it wasn't mine. I've seen them before and I know they'll come again.

dragontamer 4y ago

You'll have to forgive me, but my opinion of the cabal of GME-pumpers hyping the hell out of the stock on Reddit/WallStreetBets is not a group of conspirators I have much faith in. They create a boogieman who doesn't exist ("The big banks") without actually defining who the hell they are. All the while, they're literally conspiring to Gamma Squeeze the stock up to $1000. Then they get mad at their crappy brokerage for being crap. (I mean... maybe Robinhood shouldn't have been crap. But everyone knew it was a subpar brokerage built on hype and plenty of SEC complaints before the GME-event of January 2021). Then one of them named Roaring Kitty gets incredibly rich from the whole situation, sells off a huge chunk of their stocks, goes quiet for a while and apparently is the good guy. A few days in Congressional hearings later, it becomes blatantly obvious that no one knows what they're talking about and here we are now today. ------ I absolutely see a group of conspirators here. And its not "the big banks". I'm not sure what the legality of the whole exercise was (apparently it was legal?), but I'm not exactly seeing much altruism on the "buy buy buy" crowd. And no. Buying a terribly priced stock when everyone else is buying it isn't "saving the stock market". Its just rocking the boat and pumping the stock price higher. If that's what people want to do with their money that's their business, but don't pretend its some kind of noble effort. I'm not necessarily going to call the /r/WSB group "evil". But they're certainly not "good" either. And their obsession with finding boogiemen to yell at is dangerous mob-like rhetoric. ------ I get that it was a big social event, that large crowds moved and coordinated together, and they all felt very fun to the participants. But guess what? So was the Anti-COVID19 Trucker Convoy as well as Occupy Wall Street. It was a spontaneous mob, coordinated thanks to modern social media. That's all I see the event as honestly. It did some weird and interesting things to some smaller scale brokerages who couldn't handle the buy/sell orders, and it taught me a few things about the nature of exchanges and brokerages. But it wasn't some kind of altruistic event or heroic effort. Thanks to modern social media, I expect these spontaneous crowds to erupt into other forms and other locations... be it online or in meatspace (as per "Twitter Flash Mobs", which were probably their prototype when Social Media was younger). Maybe it was your first spontaneous internet mob, but it wasn't mine. I've seen them before and I know they'll come again.