3 ms·
It seems expected to me that the welfare state is not going to be worth it for the top quintile? That's kind of how redistribution of wealth works?
by aidenn0 5y ago
It seems expected to me that the welfare state is not going to be worth it for the top quintile? That's kind of how redistribution of wealth works?
- daenz 5y ago>Despite a generally higher cost of living in Europe, salaries across the board are lower. I was more responding to that idea: everything is more expensive, and everyone is making a lot less (not just the top quintile). Seems like a bad trade, but that's just my $0.02
- mjochim 5y agoExcept everything isn't more expensive. For example rent. Also, everyone can go see a doctor and pay nothing (not just the top quintile). All of this is if course simplified, but just to add another pair of cents.
- maccard 5y agoAnd groceries. I was _shocked_ at how expensive buying fresh food was in the US, and funnily enough, the most desired food was imported from the EU and was far more expensive. Here's a great comparison - aged parmesan cheese from the supermarket [0] [1] is $11/lb here, or $17+tax in the US. This is the same for a huge amount of ingredients too; cheeses, meats + veg. I helped a friend do his grocery shopping in a trader joes, by my best guess it was twice the price of my shop in Sainsbury's (a middle-of-the-road supermarket) [0] https://www.traderjoes.com/home/products/pdp/parmigiano-reggiano-aged-40-months-072358 https://www.traderjoes.com/home/products/pdp/parmigiano-regg... [1] https://www.sainsburys.co.uk/gol-ui/product/sainsburys-parmigiano-reggiano--taste-the-difference-200g https://www.sainsburys.co.uk/gol-ui/product/sainsburys-parmi...
- kortilla 5y ago> aged parmesan cheese from the supermarket [0] [1] is $11/lb here, or $17+tax in the US. No shit, it’s literally an import from Europe. It’s like comparing California wine prices in Las Vegas vs in Sydney. > veg. I helped a friend do his grocery shopping in a trader joes Trader Joe’s is not a grocery store for middle class people. It’s a high end convenience store. Unless you’re really well-off, you only buy a few select items from there occasionally. If you want to see prices the working/middle class pays, look at the prices at Walmart.
- rglullis 5y agoNo. Imported wine is quite often cheaper than domestic ones in the US. Also, you want to compare the quality of products and you can not base yourself on Walmart for that. The average American eats horribly compared to the European counterpart.
- kortilla 5y ago> Imported wine is quite often cheaper than domestic ones in the US. Not anything of quality. Most good wines in California that aren’t nasty blends are California wines at $10/bottle range. > want to compare the quality of products and you can not base yourself on Walmart for that. Yes you can. The milks, meats, vegetables, and fruits are fine quality-wise. “Walmart == bad quality” is a meme based on their cheap home goods. The food is fine. > The average American eats horribly compared to the European counterpart. Having lives in both places (uk, France, and Italy), the supermarkets in the US are vastly superior. The only reason an American would eat worse is if they chose frozen meals, snacks, or just straight up fast food over what’s in the grocery store. European food costs more and is of more limited variety. The quality is consistently decent though.
- maccard 5y agoGiven we're talking about why salaries are higher in the US, i think it's fair to point out the comparison of items that are possible to buy in a normal supermarket here. I searched for parmesan in Walmart and could only buy an entire wheel for ~$26/lb. The people who I'm comparing myself to in the US strive to buy imported European food, so that's the comparison I'm going to end up making. Even basic things like fresh vegetables and fresh meat far more expensive than they are in supermarkets here.
- maccard 5y agoAnd many of us who exist in the top quintile are perfectly happy with that, knowing that we are net contributors to a better place to live for others.
- daenz 5y agoDo you think they should be forced to stay? Suppose it was easy for all of those high performers (who wanted to leave) to move to the USA. You would lose out on that extra tax revenue, and it would undermine the redistribution scheme.
- rglullis 5y agoYou don't need to suppose. It already happened recently in France. When the Socialist government increased the marginal tax rate to 70% for millionaires, there was a huge capital flight and they lost revenue.
- pjerem 5y agoNo there was not a huge capital flight. This have been aborted solely because of threats from the ultra richs in France. Moreover, this law was actually pretty fair : it was applied on marginal annual revenue over 1M so it meant that you had to be actually a multi-millionaire to be concerned.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- maccard 5y agoNo, France didn't threaten to force high earners to leave, they tried to enforce a higher tax on the absolute absolute highest earners in the country. Even making 3-400k you would have been unlikely to have been affected by this. Funnily enough, you'll also notice the bluster was about people leaving to other EU states and not to the US. Also, to call the French government socialist I'd completely laughable. Maybe in comparison to somewhere like Hungary, sure.