7 ms·
Military mulls recruiting plan to enlist college athletes
- downrightmike 5y agoWasn't one of the football stars shot in the back a dozen times by his own guys?
- imwillofficial 5y agoYeah, that sucked.
- pjbeam 5y agoPat Tillman I think his name was.
- notduncansmith 5y agoWikipedia article for anyone who wants to learn more: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pat_Tillman https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pat_Tillman
- qiskit 5y agoThat was pat tillman. He wasn't in college when he enlisted. He was an established star in the NFL ( arizona cardinals ). If I remember correctly, the announcers, nfl, military glorified his enlistment. When he died, they all initially lied about how he died and tried to glorify his death in combat by the enemy and the standard "fighting for our freedom or their freedom or some bullshit". In hindsight, pretty awful decision to throw away his NFL career. Another casualty who got caught up in the war propaganda. To this day, the NFL is still part of the war propaganda. The entire nfl even wore combat fatigues during one week last season. It's amazing the amount of war propaganda we get in the NFL. Every superbowl, we get a fly-by from the air force - stealth bombers and such.
- wmeredith 5y agoEvery game, not every Superbowl. At least here in Kansas City. There's always a fly over.
- jessaustin 5y agoWhiteman AFB is like 50 air miles from Arrowhead Stadium. Anyone with a Sunday flight might as well buzz the game; it's closer than the training ranges. But yeah, the military marketing is egregious. If the Chiefs weren't in their heyday right now, I'd probably stop watching football altogether.
- rascul 5y ago> But yeah, the military marketing is egregious. I don't recall specifics nor can I pull up any source, but I remember seeing in the past something about the US military sometimes pays organizations to do flyovers.
- jessaustin 5y agoI think they do pay for lame in-stadium stuff like "let's all clap for this random war victim", but even NFL will take off a few seconds to watch fancy planes.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- jerglingu 5y agoHis enlistment was glorified, but bear in mind it was during a time when the ugly truths and outright lies of the GWOT had not been uncovered entirely. The fake claims of of WMD's in Iraq had not been outright nullified yet, and the Afghanistan campaign had not yet devolved into the goalless, meandering, whack-a-mole presence it lazily morphed into in its later years. In hindsight, sure Tillman's enlistment was a bad decision. But as we generally understand/presume his motivations, his enlistment and willingness to fight and die was for what was thought to be a noble and just cause. I happened to join the same Ranger Battalion Tillman was in after he was killed. The ground force commander at the time of Tillman's death (and perhaps whose decisions mostly attributed to Tillman's death), Major Hodne, later came back to 2nd Ranger Battalion as its commander when I was still active. He won no respect from any of us enlisted guys. Last I heard, he was a general in charge of general infantry training in Fort Benning. Fort Benning is the home of the infantry, where most basic and advanced infantry courses for the US Army are held. The irony is thick. Not writing this to say you're necessarily wrong. The two major GWOT wars in Iraq/Afghanistan were bullshit, and Tillman along with thousands of others were killed for nothing worthwhile. There's just more nuance to the whole debacle that I think are worth pointing out. Or maybe I'm just insecure at how pointless all that shit was and I'm writing this to validate my/others' actions, hard to tell.
- MaxHoppersGhost 5y agoIt was a friendly fire incident, your phrasing makes it sound like he was fragged by his own men.
- comrh 5y agoWe'll never know cause there was an intentional coverup > Jones reported that members of Tillman's unit burned his body armor and uniform in an apparent attempt to hide the fact that he was killed by friendly fire.[29] His notebook, in which, according to author Jon Krakauer, Tillman had recorded some of his thoughts on Afghanistan, was also burned
- erdos4d 5y agoIsn't there substantial evidence that he actually was? The Wiki article states he got shot 3 times in the head at less than 10 yards range, then his unit actively tried to cover up the killing as death by enemy fire. That's pretty sketchy.
- supertrope 5y agoThe official explanation is that he was hit with light machine gun fire which has higher velocity than a service rifle, making the range seem shorter.
- kevin_thibedeau 5y ago> would not include football and basketball players Naturally you wouldn't want to put professional leagues in the lurch because their billionaire owners can't scrape up the funds to run their own farm teams.
- jimbob45 5y agoShame too because football players desperately need something like this. A lot of them fall into substance abuse and homelessness after football simply because they don’t have a job or marketable skills.
- JumpCrisscross 5y ago> lot of them fall into substance abuse and homelessness after football Isn't the cognitive and emotional-regulation degradation from playing football well documented at this point?
- jimbob45 5y agoYes, there’s that, but this is beside that. Many rookies never see a second year and have no backup career planned at all.
- parineum 5y agoI'm not sure if you've seen the statistics for veterans... they aren't great either.
- wglass 5y agoSo currently, athletic scholarships are a situation where the university commits money for tuition, and the student commits to playing the sport. This proposal has the military committing to paying the tuition. The student commits to playing the sport AND to military service. Seems like this primarily benefits the university (reduced cost for scholarships) not the student.
- aidenn0 5y agoNCAA limits how many athletic scholarships a school can give out. The beneficiaries are those who would otherwise would not have received a scholarship.
- jbigelow76 5y agoSo have the NCAA lift/remove the limit.
- nickff 5y agoIt would likely benefit universities who are either lacking an athletics program due to cost, or are unable to offer 'good' athletics scholarships. As such, this program would likely provide scholarship opportunities to 'marginally talented' varsity athletes.
- whakim 5y agoI imagine that they're mostly targeting sports where the university doesn't typically offer (full) scholarships. That's probably why basketball and football aren't included. There's also the possibility that the student wouldn't be obligated to play the sport in order to get the scholarship money. Most students want to play their sport anyways.
- ren_engineer 5y agoI've read something like 75% of American youth aren't eligible for military service due to obesity and other health issues. Pretty damning that they are so desperate that trying to grab a chunk of college athletes through convoluted means because it is a viable option to get able bodied recruits Military would be better off pushing for soda and other junk food to be made illegal for national security reasons
- vostok 5y agoJust paying more seems viable too in a capitalist system.
- sofixa 5y agoIsn't the military a pretty sweet gig, financially, if you discard the whole discipline, killing and dying parts? You get paid a decent salary but almost all of your expenses are covered, so you can save a lot.
- throwoutway 5y agoAnd if you’re deployed to any dangerous area, your salary during that time is tax free (from what I’ve been told)
- daniel-cussen 5y ago> Military would be better off pushing for soda and other junk food to be made illegal for national security reasons Coca-Cola is a national security threat. Ten times worse than any Muslim terrorist organization, worse than China or Russia, maybe similar to China actually, no Coca-Cola more, as America spends more on obesity than DEFENSE. Chemical innovation? Treason. Fluoridating the water? Makes Americans fat and retarded. OK this sounds VERY incendiary but I legitimately believe it's true. Freedom of speech! Maybe I'm fucked in the head--apparenty I am, well for sure I got fucked in the head (lobotomized) from what I reconstructed but that's different than...is it different? Well I speak in good faith. Whatever is left of my brain after all that chemical innovation I uh metabolized, can't testify as to how I absorbed it because there was a lunar month of roofies...but that's beside the main thrust of my comment. I have some amount of brains and I can talk (very fortunately). I actually don't want to get flagged for saying this, I'm saying it in good faith, I can explain all these statements, but I can only answer questions once they are asked, not before. I truly believe fluoridating water makes people who drink that "water"--actually brine--fat and retarded. It retarded me, in the original sense of the word "retarded" meaning slower, Attention Deficit Disorder which is what people originally meant by "retarded" is caused by fluoridation. I can not only testify to that but quantify that to about 7 figures precision, in Hertz, with a "tempometer". Despite being super skinny skinny I know it makes me crave water from sources outside the tap, meaning Coca-Cola. Which isn't fluoridated. I budget for other water sources. I don't see it as a waste of money, some people say it's a waste, but I have no guilt, I simply can't drink brine alone why would I? Actually looking to get water delivered, basically what the tap is meant to do, but manually getting jugs. Tons of other SMART people around here do it (downtown Santiago). I'd rather have sea-water on tap than the flúor brine I get. Like drinking it feels like chewing rocks. It's bad for cooking, it's bad for showering in...actually thinking of using the jugs for bath water, it's just poisonous on that level. And most people, it makes fat. Crave salt, for one, to get the right halide (chlorine) balance instead of fluorine. Sugary drinks to maintain brain function to compensate for the electronegativity and therefore activation energy of fluorine occupying the chlorine-ion channels. Sometimes both fat and retarded. Fluoride atoms are the most powerful atom by far, nothing else compares in reactivity, they react with all but three chemicals, those being three pure noble gases. A select minority of noble gases don't react with fluorine. And they put it in everybody's water. For their teeth! The single most unreactive part of the human body, it's supposed to react with that in two known ways and literally no way with no other part of the human body! Like do I look like I'm made of helium?
- howmayiannoyyou 5y agoConscription. If you want to incentivize military service then make it mandatory and many of the best candidates will enlist in exchange for some influence over their military occupation. If the worker shortage persists, and all indications are it will, this is a probable outcome. To @downrightmike who thought the Pat Tillman tragedy was worthy of mention in such a disrespectful way, the guy's sacrifice is awe inspiring regardless & your spin on what happened is inaccurate.
- chrisseaton 5y agoThe military doesn't want conscription. They want people who want to be there.
- dragonwriter 5y ago> The military doesn't want conscription. The political leadership doesn't want conscription because it makes the public care a lot more about decisions to use the military.
- JumpCrisscross 5y ago> the worker shortage persists, and all indications are it will, this is a probable outcome Conscription would be political suicide. The better bet is on more automation to better leverage a thinner spread of recruits.
- version_five 5y agoThis is one of those "Peak NH" comments, no offense meant. Conscription may be politically unpopular, but pretending that automation will be a solution to declining army enlistment anytime soon is pretty out of touch with reality
- JumpCrisscross 5y ago> Conscription may be politically unpopular, but pretending that automation will be a solution to declining army enlistment anytime soon is pretty out of touch with reality Sorry, not saying automation is the solution. If China bombs Guam, yes, we'll need conscription. But conscription is far from "probable." I'm simply arguing that Congress pumping godawful quantities of money into automation is more likely than POTUS enacting a draft.
- swarnie 5y agoSurely you have other ways of feeding the ridiculous military machine without hunting down promising talent in the process.... Maybe give the Twitch channel another shot.
- motohagiography 5y agoThis is a great strategy. It expands athletic scholarships, which has an automatic combination of diversity, accessability, and merit by itself, and then gets people with degrees through the military.
- ScoobleDoodle 5y agoMy take is: this is why president Biden doesn’t cancel college student debt. US is a volunteer military and without the college tuition carrot vastly fewer people would join the military.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- rasz 5y agoWorked for Intel: "House: I remember you, talking about the technical sales engineers, and also Gelbach saying, we're going to go out and we're going to find those B and C grade-engineering students who were active in athletics or they were in fraternities and they had a personality. We're not going to try to hire the A students. We're going to hire the guys who had all these extracurricular activities going on." 'Intel Crush Panel' Computer History Museum also: DO YOUR PART! Everyone is doing their Part, are you? The War Effort needs YOUR Effort! At Home, at Work, at School in your community. Heinlein was on the point https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5QmvEbphF8c https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5QmvEbphF8c