3 ms·
>I don't think it's that complicated The complicated part that I have spent many hours trying to understand is how more CO2 increases the greenhouse effect if
by s1artibartfast 5y ago
>I don't think it's that complicated
The complicated part that I have spent many hours trying to understand is how more CO2 increases the greenhouse effect if the the frequencies it absorbs are already 100% absorbed.
If current CO2 PPM absorbs 100% of the IR it can interact with, why does X+1 PPM have positive forcing? The feedback loop is already maxed out?
If I shine a flashlight at a concrete wall, it doesn't matter if I make the wall thicker.
- NumberWangMan 5y ago> The complicated part that I have spent many hours trying to understand is how more CO2 increases the greenhouse effect if the the frequencies it absorbs are already 100% absorbed. I'm curious where you're getting the figure that the relevant frequencies are 100% absorbed, I didn't think it was that high, but I'm far from an expert on this. I don't think you can ever get to 100%, just arbitrarily close -- there's always the chance that a given photon will get lucky and escape without hitting any CO2 molecule. But I think that if every IR molecule that was radiated from earth hit a CO2 molecule, what would happen after that first absorption would matter. The photon would get re-radiated with an equal chance to go in any direction. If it goes up, great, it escapes into space -- but the more CO2, the more of a chance that it gets absorbed again and re-radiated back down. So it's not a concrete wall, it's like a field of gopher holes with gophers that will take any golf ball that falls into their hole and chuck it out randomly. Even if the field is dense enough that you can't roll a golf ball directly across it without going into at least one hole, if you increase the density of gopher holes more, it still lowers the chance that the ball will make it to the other side. *edit - This article[1] I just found goes more into the math, it helped clarify it a bit for me. [1] https://www.geoexpro.com/articles/2022/04/recent-advances-in-climate-change-research-part-xiv-the-doom-of-a-photon-on-a-random-walk https://www.geoexpro.com/articles/2022/04/recent-advances-in...
- s1artibartfast 5y ago>I'm curious where you're getting the figure that the relevant frequencies are 100% absorbed, I didn't think it was that high, but I'm far from an expert on this. Last time I researched this I saw various estimates that IR in the CO2 absorptions bands only makes it 10-25 meters before it 99% of it is absorbed by CO2. Your link gives and average distance of 2.6m for IR in the CO2 absorption band. >Assume that [C]=400 ppm. The mean free path becomes 2.646m so that N=3024. The probability of returning to the Earth becomes p(1)=0.9997. A photon with frequency or wavenumber near the centre of the absorption band is virtually certain to make the return to Earth. If the CO2 concentration is doubled, the probability doesn’t change much; it becomes p(1)=0.9998. Any CO2 increase has minor effect on the photons in the center of the absorption band. This part of the band is ‘saturated’. The website and other papers I have read seem to argue that it is not the majority of photons in the center of the emission and absorption band, but a much smaller number of off band photons in the "wings" that matter for the greenhouse effect. When I have tried to read about how this works, I get bogged down by the complexity of the science, and a lot of different arguments from the climate skeptic community which I don't have the foundational understanding to reject. They say that the shoulder theory is bunk because it ignores interactions between CO2 and other molecules. Instead of photons bouncing from CO2 to CO2, they say that the CO2 passes the energy off to nitrogen and oxygen. I don't really give too much weight to the climate skeptic criticism, but I do have to acknowledge that greenhouse effect is a lot more complicated than taught in grade school and there is still a lot of active research using extremely simplified models trying to model how it works from first principles with a lot of exclusions and assumptions. like the paper cited in the link you shared from 2012. Thank you for sharing the link, I will take some time to try to read and digest it.
- NumberWangMan 5y ago> Assume that [C]=400 ppm. The mean free path becomes 2.646m so that N=3024. The probability of returning to the Earth becomes p(1)=0.9997. A photon with frequency or wavenumber near the centre of the absorption band is virtually certain to make the return to Earth. If the CO2 concentration is doubled, the probability doesn’t change much; it becomes p(1)=0.9998. Any CO2 increase has minor effect on the photons in the center of the absorption band. This part of the band is ‘saturated’. Ok, so as I'm thinking about this, and forgetting about the edges of the absorption bands -- in steady state, all the heat of the sun must be radiated out into space, otherwise the earth would be hot enough to have killed off all life millions of years ago. When you think about it, an IR photon that returns to earth is not really done, it doesn't get "stuck" to the earth. The surface of the earth either reflects it back up, or absorbs it and its energy, and then re-emits it some time later. Even with 0.9997 probability of returning to earth, if you try enough times, you'll eventually escape, and photons get a lot of tries, really fast. That 0.0003 probability matters, and if you change it to 0.0002, it seems to me like it's a really, really big deal. To take it the other way -- if any given IR photon had, say, a 50% chance of escaping the earth, my intuition says that it would let the earths temperature drop extremely drastically at night, like the moon or mercury. The sheer speed at which photons get "tries" to escape means that the greenhouse gas blanket has to absorb and send back almost all photons in order for the earth not to become icy every night.
- photochemsyn 5y agoSo that question was addressed in the 1950s I believe by one Gilbert Plass who was initially involved in getting data for infrared guidance systems for air-to-air rockets (homing in on jet engines). The simple answer is that those frequencies are not saturated at altitude, i.e. 12 km up or so. Hence this is where CO2 exerts most of its effect. For a full discussion: > "Plass pursued a thorough set of one-dimensional computations, taking into account the structure of the absorption bands at all layers of the atmosphere. In 1956 he explained clearly, for the first time, that the water vapor absorption lines did not block the quite different CO2 absorption spectrum, adding that there was scarcely any water in the upper atmosphere anyway. He further explained that although some of the CO2 band itself was truly saturated, there were many lines to the side where adding more of the gas would increase the absorption of radiation. His arguments and calculations showed convincingly that adding or subtracting CO2 could seriously affect the radiation balance, layer by layer through the atmosphere, altering the temperature by a degree or more down to ground level." https://history.aip.org/climate/Radmath.htm https://history.aip.org/climate/Radmath.htm Here's an additional bit of data that explains this rather oft-repeated old trope about CO2 saturation: > "The early experiments that sent radiation through gases in a tube, measuring bands of the spectrum at sea-level pressure and temperature, had been misleading. The bands seen at sea level were actually made up of overlapping spectral lines, which in the primitive early instruments had been smeared out into broad bands. Improved physics theory and precise laboratory measurements in the 1940s and after encouraged a new way of looking at the absorption. Scientists were especially struck to find that at low pressure and temperature, each band resolved into a cluster of sharply defined lines, like a picket fence, with gaps between the lines where radiation would get through."