4 ms·
>they should have that money as soon as it clears right? You'd think so, but no. The brokerages can't use customer funds to do that. They have to front the cos
by gruez 5y ago
>they should have that money as soon as it clears right?
You'd think so, but no. The brokerages can't use customer funds to do that. They have to front the cost themselves.
>We cannot use customer funds to front that cost due to regulation. So the brokerages or the clearing firms have to go into their own pockets to do it.
https://finance.yahoo.com/video/heres-why-robinhood-restricting-users-173049721.html https://finance.yahoo.com/video/heres-why-robinhood-restrict...
- SilasX 5y agoFYI to anyone reading: gruez and I had an exchange a while back where I tried to pin down what the collateral is accomplishing and why the customers couldn’t buy even with settled funds. I don’t think it resulted in a satisfactory explanation but it goes over a bunch of the same questions being asked on this story, and I still think it’s useful to help isolate what part doesn’t make sense. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27693578 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27693578
- deschutes 5y agoHere's what I gather from that thread. The bottom line is that the retail trader stays whole in the case the trade fails to clear. If the broker was allowed to use the retail trader's money for collateral it would either not really be collateral or it would be at risk of being forfeit. You can't have it both ways.
- SilasX 5y agoBut that wouldn’t make sense as being a constraint that the Robinhood’s upstream counterparties would demand, since the collateral is purportedly to protect them. No one has ever argued this point in terms of “oh we just wanted to make sure no one took your money without giving shares”, or, if they did, they are really bad at communication. Edit: note that this other authoritative explanation claims the failure mode is RH holding the bag for a client not depositing funds as promised.
- deschutes 5y agoIt makes perfect sense for a regulation that intends to protect the retail customer's interests. I suspect Robinhood would put customer money up for collateral if they were allowed to do so.
- SilasX 5y agoWhat is that responding to? The problem is the lack of a consistent threat model for whom you're protecting and what you're protecting them from. Half the time it's "the consumer could reneg on the purchase" and half the time it's "the shares could be stoken from the consumer". And 100% of the time, the super-confident, I-get-this-and-you-don't explainer doesn't realize the inconsistency.
- deschutes 5y agoI'm not sure what you're driving at. The sibling clearly outlines a scenario where the collateral is lost. But it almost doesn't matter so long as you assume the clearinghouse isn't some vestigial intermediary. I can't answer why customers with cash in hand couldn't directly settle the trade. Maybe most of the time it doesn't matter and it's easier for brokers to have one settlement process. Maybe the industry has come to depend on the delayed settlement in some unrelated way. Maybe it's something that hasn't fully been adopted due to change taking time. Maybe the referenced regulations get in the way of an uncollateralized process.
- SilasX 5y ago>I'm not sure what you're driving at. The sibling clearly outlines a scenario where the collateral is lost. They outlined a (dubious) scenario where the collateral protected the clearinghouse or counterparties, not the retail consumer, which your original comment appealed to. So no, you can’t mix and match and equivocate between the two justifications, and if your comment is going to appeal the latter, you can’t equate it with the former. >I can't answer why customers with cash in hand couldn't directly settle the trade. Maybe… Okay, I hate to come down hard on you, since you’re far from the only (or worst) offender, but … if what you’re saying is true, you really shouldn’t be commenting on this thread. If you’re coming in with the view that Gamestonkers are just misinformed about how things work, and you want to tell them so, it’s incumbent on you to actually understand “how things work” at a deeper level, which includes being able to answer follow up questions. I linked an earlier thread where I, following the Hacker ethos, applied my curiosity to pin down a model that would explain the Robinhood failure and reconcile any deficiencies in my worldmodel. That exchange was an attempt to pin things down rigorously, and a rigorous answer requires that you be able to answer questions like that. So this really isn’t the place for “fake it till you make it” or throwing around wild speculation. If you speak authoritatively while lacking the requisite understanding, then you’re adding noise, not signal. It is not a strike against you that you lack that understanding. Heck, I’m the same way! But it is when you want to call others’ understanding deficient. And it does mean you should leave room for others who can (justifiably) offer understanding.