4 ms·

When it comes to Oatly... It tastes good, but that's because it contains plenty of sugars. You'll notice the difference when you make your own oat milk from oat

When it comes to Oatly... It tastes good, but that's because it contains plenty of sugars. You'll notice the difference when you make your own oat milk from oats. It's tastes quite terrible actually. Oatly adds enzymes to break down the starches to sugar. https://www.gq.com/story/oatly-nutrition-ipo https://www.gq.com/story/oatly-nutrition-ipo

oh_sigh 4y ago
Oatly original has 7g of sugar - 1 cup of whole cows milk has 12 g of sugar. So it is still significantly less sugar than cow's milk. I drink planet oat milk, and that only has 4g of sugar and tastes good to me.
- unicornporn 4y ago
  Oatly's primary sugar, maltose, has 2.3 times the blood sugar impact as lactose, the primary sugar in cow's milk. Maltose has a glycemic index of 105, compared to 46 for lactose.[1] [1] https://www.jeffnobbs.com/posts/oatly-responds-in-defense-of-its-ingredients https://www.jeffnobbs.com/posts/oatly-responds-in-defense-of...
  - googlryas 4y ago
    Ok, but if Oatly is 100% maltose, it has only a slightly higher glycemic index than cow's milk. But the aforementioned planet oat is still lower(assuming it is 100% maltose)
- zihotki 4y ago
  I double-checked the amount of sugar in milk and in my area, Netherlands, all milk (whole or not) contains less than 5g of sugar per 100g. While Oatly has indeed about 7g per 100g. So it's quite the opposite, oatly has significantly more sugar with higher glycemic index.
  - Reason077 4y ago
    The US nutrition label lists sugars per serving, which is 240ml. So according to the US rules it's 7g sugar per 240ml, not per 100g (or 100ml). The US Oatly label lists "Total Carbohydrate 16 g, Includes 7 g added sugars" per 240ml. The UK Oatly label lists "Carbohydrate: 6.6 g, of which sugars: 4.0 g" per 100ml. Pretty sure the Netherlands product and label is the same as the UK one.
causi 4y ago
Is that not a good thing? Starches break down into sugars in the body anyway and presumably have similar deleterious effects on the liver. May as well enjoy tasting them.
- zihotki 4y ago
  It is not, timing matters. It takes some time for starches to break into sugar therefore the release of sugars is not spiking. Glycemic index was created to show a difference between good and bad carbs.
zukzuk 4y ago
So does cow milk. 7g* of added sugar in a cup of Oatly, about 8g of various sugars in a cup of milk. Oatly add the sugar to more closely simulate the flavour of milk, but it tastes about as sweet... and both are way too sweet if you ask me. *The nutrition profile is a bit more complicated as I think they add enzymes to break down starches in the oats, so you end up with more sugar even though it's not technically "added".
- unicornporn 4y ago
  Oatly's primary sugar, maltose, has 2.3 times the blood sugar impact as lactose, the primary sugar in cow's milk. Maltose has a glycemic index of 105, compared to 46 for lactose.[1] [1] https://www.jeffnobbs.com/posts/oatly-responds-in-defense-of-its-ingredients https://www.jeffnobbs.com/posts/oatly-responds-in-defense-of...
- Reason077 4y ago
  > "7g of added sugar in a cup of Oatly" Oatly (and most other oat milks) do NOT "add" any sugar! The sugar in oat milk comes from the starch naturally present in the oats, which is broken down into sugars by amylase enzymes during the production process. (AFAIK the "added sugars" wording on US Oatly labels is due to a technicality of US labelling laws. It's doesn't say that on European labels.)
Reason077 4y ago
> "When it comes to Oatly... It tastes good, but that's because it contains plenty of sugars." Absolutely, but that's also true of cows milk. The sugars in oat milk are a bit simpler (primarily maltose rather than lactose), which gives a lower glycemic index, but the total sugar content isn't much different. Either way, if you compare them to something like fruit juice or full-sugar soft drinks, the sugar content is still pretty low.
- unicornporn 4y ago
  > The sugars in oat milk are a bit simpler (primarily maltose rather than lactose), which gives a lower glycemic index That would lead to a higher glycemic index? >> Either way, if you compare them to something like fruit juice or full-sugar soft drinks, the sugar content is still pretty low. From https://www.jeffnobbs.com/posts/oatly-responds-in-defense-of-its-ingredients https://www.jeffnobbs.com/posts/oatly-responds-in-defense-of...: Even with the slightly lower glycemic index for maltose due to the soluble fiber content, I get more or less the same result for Oatly’s blood sugar impact: a glycemic index of 77 (previously 79) and a glycemic load of 18.4 (previously 19.0) for a 12 oz portion; still about the same blood sugar impact as a 12 oz cola, which has a glycemic index of 63 and glycemic load of 20.8.

oh_sigh 4y ago

Oatly original has 7g of sugar - 1 cup of whole cows milk has 12 g of sugar. So it is still significantly less sugar than cow's milk. I drink planet oat milk, and that only has 4g of sugar and tastes good to me.

unicornporn 4y ago
Oatly's primary sugar, maltose, has 2.3 times the blood sugar impact as lactose, the primary sugar in cow's milk. Maltose has a glycemic index of 105, compared to 46 for lactose.[1] [1] https://www.jeffnobbs.com/posts/oatly-responds-in-defense-of-its-ingredients https://www.jeffnobbs.com/posts/oatly-responds-in-defense-of...
- googlryas 4y ago
  Ok, but if Oatly is 100% maltose, it has only a slightly higher glycemic index than cow's milk. But the aforementioned planet oat is still lower(assuming it is 100% maltose)
zihotki 4y ago
I double-checked the amount of sugar in milk and in my area, Netherlands, all milk (whole or not) contains less than 5g of sugar per 100g. While Oatly has indeed about 7g per 100g. So it's quite the opposite, oatly has significantly more sugar with higher glycemic index.
- Reason077 4y ago
  The US nutrition label lists sugars per serving, which is 240ml. So according to the US rules it's 7g sugar per 240ml, not per 100g (or 100ml). The US Oatly label lists "Total Carbohydrate 16 g, Includes 7 g added sugars" per 240ml. The UK Oatly label lists "Carbohydrate: 6.6 g, of which sugars: 4.0 g" per 100ml. Pretty sure the Netherlands product and label is the same as the UK one.

causi 4y ago

Is that not a good thing? Starches break down into sugars in the body anyway and presumably have similar deleterious effects on the liver. May as well enjoy tasting them.

zihotki 4y ago
It is not, timing matters. It takes some time for starches to break into sugar therefore the release of sugars is not spiking. Glycemic index was created to show a difference between good and bad carbs.

zukzuk 4y ago

So does cow milk. 7g* of added sugar in a cup of Oatly, about 8g of various sugars in a cup of milk. Oatly add the sugar to more closely simulate the flavour of milk, but it tastes about as sweet... and both are way too sweet if you ask me. *The nutrition profile is a bit more complicated as I think they add enzymes to break down starches in the oats, so you end up with more sugar even though it's not technically "added".

unicornporn 4y ago
Oatly's primary sugar, maltose, has 2.3 times the blood sugar impact as lactose, the primary sugar in cow's milk. Maltose has a glycemic index of 105, compared to 46 for lactose.[1] [1] https://www.jeffnobbs.com/posts/oatly-responds-in-defense-of-its-ingredients https://www.jeffnobbs.com/posts/oatly-responds-in-defense-of...
Reason077 4y ago
> "7g of added sugar in a cup of Oatly" Oatly (and most other oat milks) do NOT "add" any sugar! The sugar in oat milk comes from the starch naturally present in the oats, which is broken down into sugars by amylase enzymes during the production process. (AFAIK the "added sugars" wording on US Oatly labels is due to a technicality of US labelling laws. It's doesn't say that on European labels.)

Reason077 4y ago

> "When it comes to Oatly... It tastes good, but that's because it contains plenty of sugars." Absolutely, but that's also true of cows milk. The sugars in oat milk are a bit simpler (primarily maltose rather than lactose), which gives a lower glycemic index, but the total sugar content isn't much different. Either way, if you compare them to something like fruit juice or full-sugar soft drinks, the sugar content is still pretty low.

unicornporn 4y ago
> The sugars in oat milk are a bit simpler (primarily maltose rather than lactose), which gives a lower glycemic index That would lead to a higher glycemic index? >> Either way, if you compare them to something like fruit juice or full-sugar soft drinks, the sugar content is still pretty low. From https://www.jeffnobbs.com/posts/oatly-responds-in-defense-of-its-ingredients https://www.jeffnobbs.com/posts/oatly-responds-in-defense-of...: Even with the slightly lower glycemic index for maltose due to the soluble fiber content, I get more or less the same result for Oatly’s blood sugar impact: a glycemic index of 77 (previously 79) and a glycemic load of 18.4 (previously 19.0) for a 12 oz portion; still about the same blood sugar impact as a 12 oz cola, which has a glycemic index of 63 and glycemic load of 20.8.