6 ms·
Why I am no longer a skeptic
- derleth 15y ago> I still have no faith in anything supernatural, mystical, psychical or spiritual. I still regard the scientific method as the best way to model reality, and reason as the best way to uncover truth. ... then you're still a skeptic.
- jriddycuz 15y agoYou're missing the distinction he is drawing between belief and identity. He is specifically saying that, despite his beliefs lining up with those espoused by most self-professed skeptics, he no longer identifies as one himself, because he finds problems with using it as an identity.
- derleth 15y agoI get his distinction, I simply deny that the problems he cites are any part of being a skeptic.
- archgoon 15y agoDon't miss out on his enemies list at the end, including Randall Munroe. Short version: There are issues with the skeptical movement. I don't want to self identify with, nor associate with them. Scientists are well respected and have huge political clout, so there is no point in actively defending science.
- wisty 15y agoWhat a tool. His main issue with Randall Munroe seems to be that by drawing smart, capable female characters; Randall is opressing innocent female stick-figures, by coercing them into his own ideal. I guess he should also be tried for war crimes, after all the stick figures he's killed off. (Yes, you can twist words till the make all sorts of stupid conclusions. I guess the OP has already made that point, though).
- Alex3917 15y agoI think his criticism is that all of XKCD's female characters fit the archetype of what TV Tropes calls the Manic Pixie Dream Girl: http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/ManicPixieDreamGirl http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/ManicPixieDreamGi... This isn't female empowerment, it's just a masturbatory trope that's being (allegedly) used as a shortcut to doing actual storytelling or character development. I don't really take any position on his use of female characters. But I will say that the whole "Science: It works, bitches" tagline that Randall has popularized is perhaps the ultimate example of the intellectual laziness and lack of curiosity that currently characterize the self-proclaimed skeptic community. This is exactly what he's talking about when he talks about how skeptics uncritically embrace logical positivism despite the fact that it's been completely rejected by the philosophical community.
- wisty 15y agoThat might say a little about Randall and maybe his readership, but I don't see how it's a real problem. Some women may feel pressured to raise their arms in the air, and act enthusiastic. It's not a repeal of the Nineteenth Amendment. It's not even 30 seconds of prime time TV. And Randall has done a lot of notionally feminist cartoons. I'm sure a hardline feminist can pick holes in his work, but I still think he's going to shift most of his readers towards a more feminist viewpoint; especially the sad cases who think that women can't do math. Feminists seem to think that because sexism has caused a lot of bad things (women barred from universities, few female CEOs, etc); anything that can be accused of being remotely sexist is an objectively bad thing. That's just braindead. Once you put things in perspective, I think xkcd is OK. Science does work. It doesn't work for everything. If you can point me in the direction of a philosophical framework that you think has a remote chance of getting me the right answer faster, please do. I'm curious, most skeptics are - it's just that we've been let down by some shady operators (i.e. pretty much anyone claiming that they can teach you how to think) and don't want to get taken in again. I'm not saying the skeptics community doesn't have some sweaty, closed-minded geeks who like nothing better than sneering and intellectual mud-wrestling. I don't hang out on skeptic forums, so I wouldn't really know. I suppose he's just mentioning them as an ad hominem attack on logical positivism, to gives some weight to the rest of the post.
- llambda 15y agoI feel like there is a good deal to be said against skepticism as defined by the author of this article. However the tone of this post borders strongly on the political and seems to be little more than a diatribe; we see Dawkins is highlighted with a quotation attacking a fellow skeptic. This section is a poorly constructed ad hominem[1] attack. If we want to criticize skepticism we don't need to rely on such easy targets and certainly can in fact actually focus on skepticism as an ideology rather than skepticism as a set of people who are self-proclaimed practitioners of it. As such I've flagged this submission because I don't really think this kind of thing has a place on HN; we aren't here to discuss political or sociopolitical ideologies, this is intrinsically off-topic for this community. Sure, it may be interesting, and I have to admit I side with the author, but nonetheless, this is at best a rant littered with logical fallacies and is only loosely tied to the discussions of startups and hacking. That's my two cents. [1] "As is typical of hatemongers, Dawkins is careful not to name his target directly: instead, he works with insinuation -- though that said, calling the victim "Muslima" is particularly crass." Addendum: let's keep politics (yes, socio-political and ideological discourse in general is meant to be included when I say "politics") off of HN, please. :)
- Alex3917 15y agoThat's only the first couple sections of the essay, the rest of it is largely about epistemology. If anything he doesn't go far enough in the latter half, e.g. there is a compelling argument to be made that western medicine is basically a cult with a lot in common with scientology: http://www.erowid.org/library/review/review.php?p=269 http://www.erowid.org/library/review/review.php?p=269 Not that there isn't anything good about pharmacology, it's probably the best system we have for certain kinds of research, but at the same time these self-proclaimed skeptics have basically teamed up with big pharma to defend the worst parts of it. I think the fact that there are so many skeptics lining up to defend the epistemological one-truth world that big pharma has bought and paid for is pretty disgusting.
- marijn 15y agoIf it has no place on HN, let the voting take care of that. It appears this link has vanished off the front page, though it is doing quite well in terms of score. Probably because it was flagged. That's not how open dialogue works.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- jriddycuz 15y agoI think this only furthers the author's point about skepticism-as-an-identity. When you apply the term "real skeptic," you necessarily invoke some form dogma about what skepticism is. This can be avoided by not treating skepticism as an identity, but rather a name for a collection of tools. Like the OC said, it's being skeptical about things rather than being a skeptic.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- smoyer 15y agoWhy spend all that time defining who you aren't? Put that same energy into creating something of worth!
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- true_religion 15y ago> Too often, the skeptic nerd who tries to display his women-friendly credentials ends up revealing himself only as a sexist creep. He's all in favour of women, as long as they satisfy his own ideals of what a woman should be. Wait... let's flip the script here a little bit. If some man only likes and approves of other men that fit his ideals, is he being sexist? What does sex even have to do with this?
- scotty79 15y agoI think attitude presented by this guy is nailed here: http://xkcd.com/774/ http://xkcd.com/774/