4 ms·
I agree. It seems "compromise" is increasingly used as "What I'm proposing should be considered the compromise and you should listen to me". There's no real deb
by giantg2 5y ago
I agree. It seems "compromise" is increasingly used as "What I'm proposing should be considered the compromise and you should listen to me". There's no real debate. Nobody tries to address the other side's concerns. And then we do have, as you say, some fundamental differences in world views and experiences that sometimes form an impasse.
- mbg721 5y agoEverybody has internalized the idea that if you ask for twice what you really want, meeting in the middle will give you the thing you actually wanted. So if you notice that the other side is doing the same thing, you double it again...
- giantg2 5y agoThey never read Never Split The Difference. Negotiations are supposed to be value based and each side should listen to the true concerns of the other. That said, I don't think the political sides are really asking for twice what they want. It seems very clear on most subjects that they really do want all that they are asking for, but will occasionally accept less and continuing to press for the rest in the long run.
- mbg721 5y agoThinking about it, I think you're right that the political sides aren't doing that. The Culture-War wedge issues that are the most polarizing don't really have a halfway; we've seen that with abortion, for example, for decades. All the halfway positions are unsatisfying to everyone, and the issue is still there.
- floren 5y agoAs someone who follows gun laws, "compromise" often takes this form: Lawmakers: "We intend to outlaw all semi-automatic rifles with scary black stocks" Gun owners: "Please don't do that." Lawmakers: "Ok, let's compromise, we'll only outlaw scary rifles with collapsing stocks and vertical handgrips on the front." (time passes) Lawmakers: "There is a terrible loophole in our gun regulations..."
- KerrAvon 5y agoHas it not occurred to you that we actually need tighter gun laws if we want fewer dead children? https://www.reuters.com/world/us/guns-became-leading-killer-us-children-teens-2020-analysis-shows-2022-04-25/ https://www.reuters.com/world/us/guns-became-leading-killer-...
- mbg721 5y agoI've heard that the definition of "assault rifle" is mainly cosmetic; to what extent is that true?
- floren 5y agoPer Wikipedia, the US army defines an assault rifle as: "short, compact, selective-fire weapons that fire a cartridge intermediate in power between submachine gun and rifle cartridges." Selective-fire means it's not just semi-automatic (one shot per trigger pull), it can also be set to fully auto (shoots as long as you pull the trigger) or burst (shoots a few rounds when you hold the trigger, then stops). These are essentially unavailable to the average civilian. In popular usage, though, "assault rifle" means a short semi-automatic rifle with a plastic stock--anything that looks like a modern military rifle. Heck, I bet if you chopped down grandpa's bolt-action .30-06 deer rifle and put it in a black plastic stock, somebody would call it an assault rifle. Personally, I think the AR-15 pattern rifle is a deeply boring and unattractive firearm. It's also become a symbol in a culture war: a terrifying "weapon of war" to some, a statement of rebellion and "owning the libs" to others. At the end of the day, though, there's just not a hell of a lot of difference between an AR-15 civilian rifle and, say, the Ruger Mini-14, except that the latter has a less scary wood stock.
- giantg2 5y ago'Per Wikipedia, the US army defines an assault rifle as: "short, compact, selective-fire weapons that fire a cartridge intermediate in power between submachine gun and rifle cartridges."' The etymology supports this as well, going back to the first ones during WW2. One thing to note, is that the law can define terms however they want. So places are applying their own novel definitions, largely involving cosmetic features or make/model. Of course one other thing to point out is that the assault rifle bans are mostly a red herring given the relatively low contribution to homicides.
- KerrAvon 5y agoThat’s because — by design — the culture war issues do not have a compromise position. The compromise on abortion was Clinton’s “safe, legal, and rare” — and it didn’t solve the problem. The compromise on guns was a ban on assault weapons, background checks and letting states regulate guns. It didn’t solve the problem. These issues were cultivated by right-wing think tanks over decade with the sole purpose of making it impossible for voters to even think of doing anything but electing Republicans. I’m not excusing the idiocy of the Democrats here, but you can’t both-sides the fundamentals of the culture war — it’s not a symmetrical problem.