3 ms·
My problem with advertising with regards to tech is that it subverted the majority of tech into eventually becoming an ad delivery and/or tracking mechanism: ht
by Nextgrid 5y ago
My problem with advertising with regards to tech is that it subverted the majority of tech into eventually becoming an ad delivery and/or tracking mechanism: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29513045 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29513045
I sometimes envy other, more menial jobs because the tools they use day-to-day are still tools designed to help them do their job faster instead of trying to solicit "engagement". Plumbers' wrenches or electricians' screwdrivers don't come with a little screen and buzzer to beep at you every couple hours because you haven't "engaged" with it enough.
In tech and most office jobs we are still forced to use a lot of consumer-grade "tools" (and major operating systems such as Windows, macOS, iOS and Android) which can technically be a lot more efficient (and less annoying) but aren't because of the advertising business model (and the same business model prevents them from offering a paid option).
> I have to say that I love the general notion of advertising: someone who created something awesome pays for my discovery costs.
As a consumer, I don't want to be forced to "discover" your product since in reality this "discovery" deliberately interrupts or slows down whatever other task I'm trying to do. Ironically, when I do want to discover new products, there is no actual "ad search engine" where I can enter a detailed search criteria (against the ads' targeting parameters) to find ads matching it despite it being trivial to build for any of the ad giants.
I don't have any particular problems with old-school print/magazine advertising since those are still within the control of the user - I choose when I have time to look at the magazine and be exposed to its ads and I've already pre-filtered which ads I'll see based on the general topic of the magazine.
- kite_and_code 5y agoThank you for sharing your thoughts. I learned something new via this! So, it seems like you would prefer if many of the businesses that currently choose an advertising business model choose another one. Is this correct?
- Nextgrid 5y agoThat's correct - I don't mind advertising being there as an option, just that the whole business model of it doesn't make that possible - the people who would rather pay not to see ads are those that commend the highest ad rates, so the only way out is to outright ban it or make it unprofitable with draconian regulation.
- kite_and_code 5y agoI guess there are companies that have tried to let people pay instead of showing ads but I guess that the conversation rates have been so low that the company did not achieve the same revenue than via ads. Having said that. What do you think about a regulation that companies are required to offer a pay-for-no-ads option which gives users an option that is priced at 10% above the expected value of their ad revenues?