7 ms·
What's up with the anti-Golang shitposts lately? I liked fasterthanlime better when he didn't just sound like a card-carrying Rust zealot. This isn't even abo
by zozbot234 5y ago
What's up with the anti-Golang shitposts lately? I liked fasterthanlime better when he didn't just sound like a card-carrying Rust zealot. This isn't even about the practicalities of his argument really; optics matter, and it's especially bad since the Rust community used to be known for its politeness and always being fair to other language communities.
- mattrighetti 5y agoJust a small reminder: fasterthanlime is not the Rust community
- jamesmunns 5y agoThe last time his "I want off" article was reposted[0], the comments were pretty rough, ranging from ad-hom attacks to (at best) misunderstandings of the arguments he was making. I see this article being an address to these criticisms (which are not limited to this forum, I've seen similar arguments on twitter, etc.). Pointing out shortcomings isn't really impolite or unfair. The author specifically mentioned shortcomings of Rust as well. [0]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31191700 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31191700
- rob74 5y agoPointing out shortcomings isn't impolite - writing that Go wasn't designed, but happened by accident is however (IMHO).
- clpm4j 5y agoEspecially since it was designed by computer science luminaries who are almost certainly better programmers/engineers than the author of this blog. It's also more accurate to say that Rust wasn't designed / was an accident since it was technically a side project of one guy at Mozilla.
- samhw 5y agoBoth languages were designed by probably better programmers than most in this thread. For that matter, the vast majority of successful programming languages surely were. I'm utterly lost at how that relates to anything. One can plainly be a good programmer and yet create a bad language. I'm sure you are well-informed enough to analyse his argument on its merits, even if it were written by a gang of monkeys with typewriters.
- samhw 5y ago> writing that Go wasn't designed, but happened by accident is however [impolite] That's one of the most mild and inoffensive criticisms I've ever read on the internet. You can't seriously be indignant about that.
- oxnrtr 5y agoThe truth cannot be impolite.
- masklinn 5y ago> The last time his "I want off" article was reposted[0] Of note: the last time in question was yesterday, the flagging and ad-hominems pretty obviously made lime's cupeth runneth over.
- cnasc 5y ago> the Rust community used to be known for its politeness and always being fair to other language communities I have no particular affinity for Go or Rust. As an outsider this is not how I’ve ever perceived the Rust community, because the most present and visible parts of the Rust community were people showing up and complaining that Project X didn’t use their preferred silver bullet
- collegeburner 5y agoAlso honestly it's very toxic to anybody right of center. It's the type that says "we're so accepting" when really they only are of certain stuff. Lots of pronoun people and making the mascot "non binary" is needlessly shoving their ideology down people's throat. Not a problem in the U.S. because it fits with the corporate woke ideology but sure as hell gonna be if they want more worldwide community. It's also way too hugboxxy and tbh that feels just as toxic some times as the alternative. Positivity to the point where it's obviously fake and forced and insincere. Edit: howinteresting I can't reply to your comment but you are proving my point. At least you people are being more honest that it is intended to exclude a bunch of people.
- howinteresting 5y ago
- Georgelemental 5y agoAs someone who both loves the Rust language and is very right of center, I've never found politics to pose much of a problem for the Rust community in practice. Yes there is occasional virtue signalling here and there but people don't let it get in the way of making programs that work.
- samhw 5y agoYeah, as someone who's gay and left-wing but equally irritated by the 'virtue signalling' stuff (my ideology is basically r/stupidpol), I don't find the Rust community too bad. (FWIW, I appreciate your open-mindedness. I think that's the main thing I find objectionable on (parts of) both sides of the aisle: an inability to regard those who disagree as fundamentally well-intentioned human beings who happen to hold different beliefs.)
- JyB 5y agoFrom the outside the Rust community seems so defensive about Go that it makes me very reluctant to dive deeper into Rust.
- ericbarrett 5y agoI use both & like both. Ignore the noise!
- rgrmrts 5y agoYeah, same. They’re both nice languages, they both have great tooling, and they both have areas where they shine. I don’t see them as competitors really, but “You can also implement X in Y” is a fairly useless statement, of course you can. I’m glad we have as many languages options as we do, and I enjoy writing a variety of languages for a variety of different projects. Sure, I have moments where I think “ugh why can’t I do X in language Y” or “C is cleaner in Y” etc etc. I’ve found helpful people, critics, and fanatics in every language community. Don’t let that dissuade you from learning Rust (or Go, or …)
- styluss 5y agoOne person is not the community
- asxc11 5y agoI might not agree with fasterthanlime's opinion on Go (9/10 times I would opt to use Go over Rust), but calling this post a "shitpost" is unnecessarily dismissive. The post, like his previous post on Go, contain well thought out points that add to the discussion at the very least. Also I like his sense of humour :) Edit: though, I suppose saying Go is not designed is also equally unnecessarily dismissive and hyperbolic.
- zozbot234 5y agoWell-thought out, how? It's flogging a dead horse in a transparent, deliberate attempt to create controversy and flamebait. That's a shitpost pretty much by definition.
- unethical_ban 5y agoI don't think it's obvious this was done in bad faith, even if the author is at times flippant.
- ibejoeb 5y ago> Portland Oregon, the capital of grunge, coffee, poor weather and whiteness it's kinda a shitpost
- biorach 5y agoIt's sarcasm, dumb humor - not trying to be inflammatory, or provocative - i.e. not shitposting. And let's face it, Portland kinda takes itself too seriously.
- hsnewman 5y agoI moved from Austin TEXAS to Portland to get away from the heat and forced conservitism. I also moved to Portland for the weather (cool and wet vs hot as hell and dry). I don't have to use my air conditioner! As for Portland taking itself too seriously, are you serious? Portland has so many quirky things that the conservative states don't have(much less putting walls up and making some people, making 2nd class citizens ((yes, voting rights)), and you say Portland is too serious? Good luck with that gaslight.
- unethical_ban 5y agoCalling a well documented blog post, even one you disagree with, a "shitpost" should be an embarrassment to you. Guy makes a blog post about Go a few years ago. It gets posted here time and time again, not of his doing. A bunch of people challenge his premises, so he makes another post diving deeper into his arguments. So what? What's up with the literal hundreds of "Golang is amazing" posts this site has had? Is someone attempting to express dissent clearly that much of a bother?
- rob74 5y agoBut he doesn't dive deeper! If anything, he's more shallow. This just doesn't read like an honest appraisal of Go's pros and cons to me, he already has his mind set from the beginning (ok, we knew that two years ago already) and is just heaping on invectives: "one really good bit does not a platform make", "Evidently, the Go team didn't want to design a language", "Go is not adequate for production services unless your shop is literally made up of Go experts (Tailscale) or you have infinite money to spend on engineering costs (Google)" etc. etc. What makes me angry about all this Go-bashing is that it might influence decision makers against moving from things like PHP or Node to Go - which I think would be an improvement, no matter how many flaws Go may or may not have.
- biorach 5y ago> What makes me angry about all this Go-bashing It's just a language! Take it easy. The guy is not "heaping on invectives" - he's not criticizing you or someone you care about. He's pointing out some flaws in a language in a sarcastic way.
- AnimalMuppet 5y agoI would consider "Evidently, the Go team didn't want to design a language" to be at least borderline invective. From dictionary.com, definition 3: "an insulting or abusive word or expression". Yeah, that's pretty clearly insulting.
- Karrot_Kream 5y ago
- fasterthanlime 5y agoReminder that I'm not part of /any/ Rust teams, not part of the Rust foundation, etc. etc. My site is my space, and it is specifically designed to let me post my point of view without having to bear ( ) the responsibility of speaking for entire communities at once. It's important for individuals to be able to do that, and it's on everyone else to make the distinction.
- samhw 5y agoThanks for your article. I hope you can ignore all the vitriol. It's embarrassing to see what I thought was a generally intelligent community having a collective tantrum because someone was mean about its favourite toy.