3 ms·
> pigouvian taxes to try to drive desired outcomes It's an attractive idea, but we're talking about the US so there are two big problems: * AFAIK the FDA does
by tialaramex 5y ago
> pigouvian taxes to try to drive desired outcomes
It's an attractive idea, but we're talking about the US so there are two big problems:
* AFAIK the FDA does not actually have tax raising powers, and it's not going to get granted any tax raising powers, so now instead of an FDA intervention you're relying on Congress to do something. Good luck with that.
* Most tax powers which do exist lie with States, and States are always cash poor, so a "pigouvian" tax quickly becomes a must-have revenue stream. Then one of the two bad things happens. The State encourages the sin you wanted people to stop, because that drives tax revenue, or worse the State gradually adds stuff which isn't a sin to the same tax.
You wake up and either there's a TV advert paid for by the State explaining how "A pack a day helps Maggie keep her lungs strong and local schools benefit!" or else you discover that the milk on your breakfast cereal now includes "Menthol tax" because "Menthol" now includes "Dairy products, root vegetables, writing paper and non-religious ornaments" after the State found a hole in its budget.
- chad___homenim 5y ago> big problems > so now instead of an FDA intervention you're relying on Congress to do something Yes, that's the entire point of our system of government. We are not governed by executive dictate, rather by laws created by elected representatives beholden to their constituents. This is not a "big problem," it is a cornerstone for preventing your rights from being trampled upon. The straw man you write about your local state doing this is something you invented in your head.