3 ms·
The thing with CDs today is that they are merchandise, as with cassettes or vinyl or whatever. You don't buy them to listen to them, but to have them. I think
by marginalia_nu 5y ago
The thing with CDs today is that they are merchandise, as with cassettes or vinyl or whatever. You don't buy them to listen to them, but to have them.
I think this understanding is crucially necessary for musicians hopping on this "trend". Like they could make action figures or mood rings or whatever. What the fans want are buying is a tangible thing, a keepsake.
So first they need an actual fan-base that may be interested in a keepsake, and the keepsake should be worthwhile, feel luxurious. Like it doesn't need to actually be expensive, but it shouldn't feel cheap.
- l72 5y agoAgreed. I think this is why vinyl has taken off. It is much more physical then a CD. The artwork is larger and it just feels more personable. You have to be much more careful with it, and listening to it is a bigger investment. And a collection of vinyl looks great. I think a similar trend has happened with books. Certainly, e-readers are awesome. But for some things, you really want to have a physical copy. And in that case, a hardback is way better than a paperback. It is a long term keepsake and looks nice on your shelf. I think for many people, their collection of music, books, or other items allows them to show off their personality to their guests. When I go to someone's house, if they have a large bookshelf, I love to look through it to get an idea of their interests. It can be great conversation starters. You can't do that with purely digital media.
- RajT88 5y agoThe technical merits of vinyl are dubious. But it is undeniably the coolest way to listen to music. It takes effort, it is an event, a ritual executed with great care.
- kevin_thibedeau 5y agoMay as well get your coolness with cylinder recordings.
- RajT88 5y agoThat is a thing you can do too: https://tmbw.net/wiki/Wax_Cylinder_Recordings https://tmbw.net/wiki/Wax_Cylinder_Recordings
- dfxm12 5y agoCDs (and tapes and records) have some Hollywood accounting [0] around them, just as movies do. I'm sure the band would much rather you buy their t-shirt or poster or something else that their label had nothing to do with. All this depends on the band and their deal, of course, but just as well, they'll probably make the most profit off a t-shirt anyway. 0 - https://www.techdirt.com/2010/07/13/riaa-accounting-why-even-major-label-musicians-rarely-make-money-from-album-sales/ https://www.techdirt.com/2010/07/13/riaa-accounting-why-even...
- slothtrop 5y agoI think what people take for granted is this was true even before digital piracy. Most exposure to music was through radio play, and cassette copying was fairly popular from 80s onward. Rock wasn't dead yet (or at any rate, it was far more alive) and concert-going was (I think?) bigger among youth in general. Owning records was always an expensive thing and the majority of music fans didn't try to go broke buying every little thing they enjoyed. Which brings to mind, I always wonder how pop artists are reaching platinum sales today, because their physical media has zero prestige to most collectors. Is it from radio stations and DJs or something? The figures just don't make sense to me. Pop music fans use Spotify or the radio, by and large.