6 ms·
The fact that some publisher has published a book provides abosolutely zero validation to me. I choose the books I read based on: - the author: did I previou
by bryanlarsen 15y ago
The fact that some publisher has published a book provides abosolutely zero validation to me. I choose the books I read based on:
- the author: did I previously enjoy their works?
- awards: a Hugo/Nebula nomination is huge validation
- reviews: professional or bloggers or Amazon's.
- acabal 15y agoI'm not talking about a reader browsing some books and picking one based on the publisher's mark. I never really do that myself either. The "validation" I'm referring to is much more subtle: the mere fact that a book is in print and in a major bookstore--i.e. it has been picked up by a publisher--IS that validation. Because anyone can now publish themselves to the Amazon book store, that implicit validation will now become explicit as readers who start picking up indie authors realize they need someone to sort through the dreck for them. And again, I'm not just talking about a bad book--because you can get those from major publishers too--I'm talking about a certain standard of quality. Even bad books are usually typo-free, reasonably typeset, and so on. With self-published authors flooding the market, there will soon be (or already is!) a new bottom-rung of bad quality that previously didn't exist, because it was a publisher's job to weed out or fix such books. Up until today, all of us have unknowingly and implicitly been relying on the publisher's validation when buying 95% of books at a store, because without that validation they wouldn't BE in the store. That's what I'm talking about.
- poink 15y ago"readers who start picking up indie authors realize they need someone to sort through the dreck for them." Right, but you don't need a publisher to do that. Algorithms are great at it.
- TeMPOraL 15y ago> Right, but you don't need a publisher to do that. Algorithms are great at it. Not at finding factual mistakes.
- keenerd 15y ago> I'm not talking about a reader browsing some books and picking one based on the publisher's mark. I have. Killed a few hours in a Barnes & Noble the other week. Every single book on the shelves was drivel, except for the Dover and Penguin titles. (Which I bought a couple of.)
- bryanlarsen 15y agoThe validation is being in the bookstore, not whether the book is self-published or not. I'm willing to bet that if a self-published book is in the bookstore it will be better than 90% of the books in the bookstore because it means that somebody in the bookstore explicitly chose to stock that book rather than being the shovelware drivel that the publisher "recommended" they stock.
- cstross 15y agoIf you even know what a Hugo/Nebula nomination is, you're an anomaly. Unfortunately. (Says a guy who (a) has some, and (b) has seen precisely what they've done to his sales -- i.e. nothing.)
- bryanlarsen 15y agoFor what it's worth, I can't remember what caused me to start reading your books, but it probably was your awards.