2 ms·
Is there a journal that only publishes properly reproduced results? I mean, a scientific paper is basically a draft until others manages to reproduce it, only a
by Jensson 5y ago
Is there a journal that only publishes properly reproduced results? I mean, a scientific paper is basically a draft until others manages to reproduce it, only at that point is it reliable, so it seems like there would be great value having such a journal.
- czzr 5y agoThey are called review journals (and then eventually textbooks). It’s a category error to imagine any single paper is “true” - it’s basically just a bit of semi- reliable evidence that contributes towards finding the truth. The process is robust (over sufficient time) to errors in any individual paper.