4 ms·
Criticize in private, praise in public. I broke this one, and it broke a 10 year friendship which took another 5 to heal, and I decided to stop pretending to b
by ggm 5y ago
Criticize in private, praise in public.
I broke this one, and it broke a 10 year friendship which took another 5 to heal, and I decided to stop pretending to be a manager. This is a rule of life not to break if you can avoid it. Almost irreparable harm done.
- arendtio 5y agoI found the book 'How to Win Friends and Influence People' pretty helpful to understanding how important emotions are when working with people. After reading that book, you wonder how you ever dared to break that rule.
- semireg 5y agoAgreed. This is the best advice I wish I could tell myself 20 years ago.
- jatins 5y ago> I decided to stop pretending to be a manager. This is a really valuable advice. The cult like corporate brain washing often runs so deep that I see people treating their personal relationships like they'd treat work colleagues, or reports. This includes things like "having 1:1s" with their partners, or telling their friends to take "take ownership"
- eastbound 5y agoMy parents, who have succeeded to positively-educate us (never a slap or punishment, nor retribution for good behavior; just congratulate good behavior and explain), have always been to the church discussion groups, the family- and couple-oriented ones. It at least gives a framework on what to talk about, and a framework that most other couples are willing to talk about.
- darkerside 5y agoI don't think this is corporate brainwashing so much as it's acting like you are superior to the other people in your life. I agree that it's really annoying.
- sz4kerto 5y agoThis is not a universal rule. Really not -- there's an important exception that people (especially managers) tend to forget. Reflect on issues where they happened. I.e. if someone is an asshole on a meeting, you (as a leader) need to reflect on that on the meeting. You can address the details in private, but not reflecting on it in front of the people who got hurt/offended is wrong as it approves the bad behaviour.
- nvarsj 5y agoDefinitely. I've heard stories of meetings where someone openly sexually harassed a coworker, and the manager didn't say a word. Maybe they talked to them privately, but that kind of behavior needs to addressed immediately, in public, otherwise people mistake silence as tacit approval.
- darkerside 5y agoI struggle with this one, too. I don't like to criticize in public, but you CAN miss the opportunity if you are dogmatic about not doing it. One idea to do this better is, to day something about the behavior in real time without criticizing. People know that you noticed, and you can later talk about "that time in the meeting", and there's no doubt about what you're referencing. But you don't have to pick out your nuanced words in a high pressure real time scenario.
- Broken_Hippo 5y agoThis isn't the sort of advice one can blindly follow. I fully regret not criticizing people's public and private homophobia. I was young and knew the pain of having it directed at me. (Am bisexual, but folks just assumed I was lesbian in school. I hid it as much as possible at the next school). But if it is, say, work related in the US or something that someone might be embarrassed about (that doesn't harm other people)? Private is the way to go.
- strikelaserclaw 5y agoThis is true only sometimes. Some people need to be criticized in public.